Yes, this proposal addresses the challenge, as it will encourage elite members of the community to dig deep into Cardano and then present it to the community to make it easier for busy people and newbies to grasp new information about Cardano. And as meeting will be conducted on Zoom Meeting, All the members will be able to easily access the meeting. Hence, it can be assessed that proposed solution can be impactful.

I do completely agree with the presented idea in this proposal. I do believe in the offered benefits from this proposal as the Cardano community can grow both in size and quality prospect as much as the Catalyst. Since nobody can deny the popularity of blockchain or crypto’s inhabitant is more and more large, the demand that people want to join our society but starting at zero background of crypto knowledge has been increasing rapidly. In fact, most of knowledge resources primarily have the academic characteristic as well as a lot more specialized information is involved in this day and age. Therefore, we need a thing or a frame of knowledge that has been simplified so that it will incentive the users to join with us. And the encouragement in this proposal is contributed to let every member of Fimi core-team study in-depth to each of technology solution and then deliver their knowledge to Cardano community. I do think it is extremely crucial to find out such a well-qualified individual or group of people that can handle each of the issue but still ensure their capacity in meeting requirement during the inputting information process. After that, by using their languages, the new knowledge which is simplified to understand will be delivered to every person in the community. This proposal is really reliable in rising the community’s cognition of crypto as well as develop our Cardano society. Thereby contributing to the well-known of Cardano in every blockchain platform.

In order to effectively address the challenge of growing Cardano by growing the East Asian Cardano Community, this proposal will need to make a few adjustments. Having a more clear and simple channel of community within the Cardano Community seems to be the core issue of our challenges if we want to continuously grow and expand. Nevertheless, it’s not just a question of having a clear and understandable language, having audiovisual content that might explain and answer basic questions, but to design a strong communication strategy that reaches out the inner circle of Cardano Community to a wide range of a variety of newcomers. This might be the weak point of this proposal. Talk Shows can help to welcome newcomers but won’t be an efficient way of reaching out for potential newcomers if they only stay within our Community.

I found this proposal very interesting and smart in terms of the way it motivates people to contribute for the needs of the whole community. It states that more talk shows are requested by the Vietnamese community as it has so many questions about Cardano and needs it to be solved. Therefore the initiative of building a reward mechanism to attract contributors has come up. To be honest, one of the obstacles in developing the project with our blockchain is the lack of quality resources. In other words, I think it’s because they don’t know how the project can benefit them therefore they hesitate joining it. This states a problem for the pioneers of how to make contributing for the Cardano ecosystem interesting and at the same time creates more value for the community. I think that having research that makes it clear and proven how to proceed in these situations will be extremely useful for Cardano and will certainly develop for a future. Now let’s talk deeper to the impact. According to the proponents, the fast increase in the community size demands the in-time Cardano documents presented in an understandable way. Besides, there is much news about Cardano published everyday and it contains technical terms which are hard to understand without interaction with others. Because of that, it causes a high demand for full-time translators who can verbally present the news and explain the technical words in an interesting way. With what the proposers have outlined, I find those are solid and well-founded arguments with quantitative data to prove that if solved, there may be an impact on not just the FIMI Vietnamese community but also the (East Asia) Cardano community due to its practicality. Not just so, based on what they mention I assume that Cardano's awareness will be expanded leading to more people contributing ideas for the Catalyst Fund and diversifying the creation in Cardano ecosystem. During reading the solution and risks they might face, it is generally described with easy-to-understand terms and thanks to that, I have an overall image of the way they deal with difficulties. I believe it is a signal to show that they have a deep understanding about the project they are doing and will have a plan for any cases happening. For such strong and logical arguments, I am convinced and rate high for the impact part of this proposal.

"Build a rewarding mechanism to encourage elite members of the community to dig deep into Cardano and then present it to the community to make it easier for busy people and newbies to grasp new information about Cardano.", this suggestion is very practical and I like it. And Vietnam is a developing country, with young human resources with a lot of positive energy, has a lot of contributions to expanding the Cardano network in East Asia, this proposal is perfectly suitable for the challenge posed. Topics covered include: technical documents, Cardano updates, market news that will be selected and condensed by your team members with the most necessary and useful information. are the real values that the Cardano community in Vietnam needs. Because without a re-translator, newcomers or even those who already know Cardano will still not be able to fully understand the content because there are some technical terms and technical terms that are difficult to understand for them. Your team has many years of experience in operating pools, knowledge from basic to in-depth in the Cardano ecosystem is a plus. And with a large population of ~100 million people along with a rapidly growing IT force in Vietnam, promoting Cardano with the values that Cardano brings will attract more talent, contributing many interesting and high-value initiatives, contributing to the ever-growing Cardano ecosystem. When going to the website fimi.vn, this is a website for Vietnamese people, and provides a lot of valuable information such as how to install Deadelus wallet, how to create a Deadelus wallet address, how to withdraw ADA from exchanges to Cardano wallet, instructions related to operating pools, stacking. I appreciate your proposal, and hope that it will be successful and develop a strong Cardano community and promote the good values that Cardano brings. I have a small suggestion to improve the user experience at fimi.vn that is:

• Upgrade server (Hosting, VPS, Cloudserver…ect) for faster page loading speed
• In the footer: should add a small section such as CONTACT with us, then you leave the link (shortcut) like: youtube, Facebook, ….ect, then there will be More connected and professional, also better for SEO.

Vietnam is a fast-growing country in Southeast Asia with a young, tech-loving population. As finance / digital transformation / crypto issues are more and more popular, more and more people know and are interested in virtual money / block chain. But most Vietnamese people do not understand English well, so accessing and learning about blockchain still faces many difficulties. In addition, the information about cryptocurrency scams is so much that many people have a bad view of blockchain even though cryptocurrencies are only one part of the blockchain. Opening talk shows like this will help improve people's understanding of the blockchain or more specifically, the CARDANO platform, from which it will be possible to make more contributions to the CARDANO ecosystem. Raising awareness and understanding will also help people avoid being scammed.

I strongly agree that this proposal effectively addresses the challenge. The solution of the proposal is to update information about Cardano regularly, quickly, and understandably in the form of presentation to the Vietnamese community, thereby helping to develop the Vietnamese community in particular and the East Asian community in general. Vietnam is a country with a population of 99 million people, ranking 15th in the world and 3rd in Southeast Asia. Therefore, the development of the Vietnamese Cardano community will have a great impact on the world Cardano community. The goal of the project is to share information in the form of attractive and easy-to-understand presentations, which help to attract a wide range of viewers, such as newbies, developers, Ada holders, etc. This is a good point because we need to reach out to beginners, and newbies including those who don't have a technical background to expand the community quickly. Because of the above analysis, I give the project 5 points in the Impact category.

FIMI is a large information channel in Vietnam that covers many topics, ranging from macroeconomics to news updates, project analysis, and summary translation of CH Livestreams. This channel has a very solid reputation and is very powerful. Motivating the core groups of a department that consists of many groups specializing in researching the Cardano ecosystem and then sharing their findings with the community in order to assist the community in gaining the most comprehensive and up-to-date perspective possible on the progression of blockchain technology. in addition to Cardano is required and appropriate for the challenge that has been posed. The weekly monitoring and listening to information, in addition to asking questions that I do not really understand, which the groups will answer after carefully studying the projects, makes me feel very excited. It demonstrates to the community not only the consistency of the Cardano ecosystem but also the consistently increasing power of Catalyst over the course of its existence. The proponent of the proposal mentioned two difficult things when conducting live sessions as well as ADA's price slide which led to the allocation of capital to team members when discussing the risks and difficulties associated with the proposal. excellent, as well as strategies for overcoming the challenges and dangers involved. To a perfect T, I agree. This IMPACT gets a score of five points from me.

In the Vietnamese market, the group of people who know about Cardano coin, blockchain, and ADA, … Very little. And the group of people who want to learn about it is increasing. There are not many documents for Vietnamese people. So this proposal is a good idea for those who want to learn and get involved in the field. However, talkshows conducted only through Meeting Zoom will be limited in the number of people reaching out instead of doing talk shows on other platforms.

The proposition that needs to be addressed here is that Cardano users in Vietnam are looking forward to more talk shows so they can stay updated with the news and have their questions answered about Cardano. This proposal will add value to the Cardano ecosystem by Building a reward mechanism to encourage members to learn Cardano news and documents, and then introduce them to the community. The proponent proposed the following solutions: Build a reward mechanism to incentivize the elite members of the community to dig deep into Cardano then present it to the community to help busy people and newbies capture new information about Cardano easier. The talk show will be held weekly in the evening time frame through the Meet Zoom program, lasting 2 hours. All meetings will be recorded and uploaded to the FIMI youtube channel. To expand the scale of the project, the proponent already has 4 core groups and will develop a few more. Every week, any community member will propose a list of priority topics they are interested in and want to know about. Each core team group will take on a topic on the list. Then, they will go together to find information and analyze those topics. The core group with the best preparation with the most information will be selected to introduce to the community through a Zoom meeting. There is a base bonus for a Good presentation and a bonus for an excellent presentation. I believe that with the above core forces, the project can scale up by increasing core teams and effectively solve future challenges, with the impact of this proposal I believe 5*.

Suggestions that match the challenge, chat shows so they can stay up to date with the news and get their questions answered about Cardano are essential, even when I was just starting out with Cardano, I already found it difficult to get used to them because the technical documentation about Cardano and blockchain contains many technical words that are difficult to understand for newbies. The reward mechanism is a potential idea to promote the learning of newcomers to the Cardano ecosystem, which further builds the community and grows the ecosystem. Rewards are given for good presentations of presentations, I suggest organizing more activities or events, knowledge contests and applying rewards. This contributes to the diversity of the reward mechanism. In Vietnam, people seem to be familiar with Crypto, so the project with the goal of bringing them to Cardano is extremely potential. And I believe in the huge impact that the project will have if it is funded.

The project effectively addresses the challenge. Vietnam is in the top 10 in the world in terms of cryptocurrency ownership according to data from cryptocurrency payment company Triple-A. In addition, the cryptocurrency trend in 2021 made a huge impact on this country of nearly 100 million people and opened a new type of investment for the Vietnamese. Millions of Vietnamese people who every class are holding or trading crypto now including ADA and will there be millions of potential ones who want to jump into crypto in the next few years. However, the number of people who have a good understanding and awareness of cryptocurrency is very few. They just follow the trend and put their money on something they don’t know or even never heard of. Cardano is huge and in the top 10 cryptocurrencies but there are not so many Vietnamese who are well understanding it because Vietnam is not an English-speaking country so it is very hard for people knowledge and access it. Furthermore, there are tons of fake projects silking and scamming people. The key objective of this challenge is to help to grow East Asia and ADA community in East Asia. So this proposal is to give people a new reliable channel, and an easy way to get to know exactly about Cardano. It is kind of a trusted ADA information hub for Vietnamese to keep up to date and better understand the advantages of the Cardano blockchain. Vietnamese people do need an official information channel like this project. Therefore, this proposal is a very good and helpful idea to grow a better and stronger community, especially an ADA one. I strongly agree with this proposal.

This proposal brought up the issue of the imbalance between the increasing number of Cardano users in Vietnam and the amount of communicated Cardano documents and news that are easily digestible by the community. The proposed solution is to hold a weekly talkshow (primarily targeted at the Vietnam demographic) in an online meeting platform presenting news regarding Cardano and its ecosystem for 2 hours that will be uploaded in a YouTube channel later. The proposer provided some example topics that are going to be presented in these weekly talkshow, such as technical documents (Hydra, smart contract, etc.), Cardano update (Cardano 360, Hoskinson’s update livestream, etc.), and market news. The aim of this solution is to provide more information and updates about Cardano so that the community can be more informed on the state of the Cardano ecosystem. I think this proposal can add value by raising the community knowledge level by educating Cardano users about updates in the ecosystem since blockchain is a really fast moving field and with more people getting into blockchain and Cardano, the amount of information might be hard to take in for the average user. However, this project lacks the aspect of “raising the awareness levels of regular people in East Asia about blockchain and the Cardano network…”, which is the challenge setting objective, since it’s primarily targeted at people already using Cardano instead of growing Cardano’s outreach to more people that are still unaware of the blockchain and Cardano ecosystem.

The proposal to build Cardano Talk in Vietnam will be a place to share and discuss topics related to the Cardano ecosystem through weekly Zoom meetings. Participants will listen to presentations from the core team of the Fimi community, directly ask questions during the meeting for answers or discussion. This is a pretty good and effective way to provide insights and knowledge to participants in the Cardano community, especially when the Covid-19 epidemic is still happening in Vietnam, such online meetings will make sure everyone is safe and anyone can participate. Before an online presentation takes place, any member of the community will suggest a list of topics they are interested in and want to know about. This poses the challenge of the large number of different topics proposed. The proponent offered a solution of choosing only the most important topics, but this solution is quite vague, I wonder who should evaluate the proposed topics, and what criteria are given out for evaluation. The community has many members, each member has many suggestions, creating an exponential number of topics that want to be explored and covered, making it difficult to filter out topics to talk about. I come up with an idea to overcome this problem that is every week 4 core teams will research, explore and propose 2 topics/team and create polls for community members to choose. The four most voted topics will be explored and researched for online presentations. I also add some risks that the project is likely to encounter, which is the problem of the network connection system, unstable wifi, unsecured technical equipment. Online meetings will not go well if the network connection is broken or weak. Project implementers should prepare well the network system and technical equipment to ensure the online presentation.

The proposal "CardanoTalk for Vietnamese people" has identified a problem in the challenge and that problem has a great impact on the development of the Vietnamese community. It presented a problem in the development of the Cardano community, the proposed problem is suitable for the challenge, the idea is to provide a solution to help Vietnamese people more convenient in the process of searching and gathering information. of the Cardano platform. With the rapid development and more Vietnamese people interested in cryptocurrencies, Cardano needs to have an additional reliable, fast and timely information channel that responds to timely and in-depth news about cryptocurrency. Cardano from IOHK. Please present the problem clearly and convincingly. It offered solutions to a problem in the growth of the Cardano community, which is the growth of the Vietnamese community. The specific solution of the proposal is to build a youtube channel with in-depth content about ADA and the website of a professional team on Blockchain - Cardano: Fimi. Therefore, based on the recommendation engine, the human community will shorten the search time and collect quality information sources, thereby contributing to the development of the Cardano ecosystem. The team proposes to give specific examples in the presentation with arguments with specific, feasible, and highly effective numbers. It shows that the proposed team has carefully studied the development and needs of Vietnamese people, answering the question: How to increase the quantity and quality of knowledge for the Cardano community in Vietnam? The specific goal of the product you propose is: Providing knowledge and information to Cardano related people by thematic video, The talk show will be held weekly in the evening time frame via Fimi youtube channel. Besides, building a reward mechanism to encourage elite members of the community to learn deeply about Cardano and then present it to the community to help busy people and newcomers grasp new information about Cardano easily. than. The proposal identified a number of risks in the implementation process and proposed solutions to overcome all those risks. You have pointed out two risks in the process of doing work and have solutions to overcome and limit those risks. In the first risk, the proposed team points out the risk of ADA Slippage. Sometimes ADA price drops suddenly, we can't sell ADA for USD or VND in time. This may leave you with insufficient budget to reward presenters and stakeholders. Leading to the disincentive of participants' interests and the success of the proposal and its solution is the request for additional funding ($2,000) to reserve this. In the second risk, the proposed team took a risk because the community members requested too many topics and overcome by selecting only some of the most important topics.. However, I have suggestions for the group. about the solution to overcome and limit the risk that you have pointed out. In the second risk, I want you to solve the problem in more detail, develop criteria to choose the most important topic, this will help you convince the community to trust the project team more, besides knowing how to filter information when receiving. I rate: 5 points.

The proposal is fully aligned to the challenge statement as it intends to build a rewarding mechanism to encourage members to dig deep into cardano and present it to the community in Vietnam.

The proposal justifies that it is a  strategic plan to invest, because there are users who struggle to understand cardano documents, technical words and information also there are users who prefer verbal presentation over written document for better understanding and with this project it is highly likely that there will be an increase in the number of users in Vietnam and immense growth of cardano community in Vietnam .

I found it interesting how this project will have a huge influence on both community and cardano ecosystem that is, they just don't intend to only create talk shows to provide news or document translation but gives ADA holders better understanding of cardano block chain technology advantages and strengthen their belief in the future of cardano.In addition to this it will promote cardano technology and get more developers in the ecosystem and  thus it clearly articulates how it adds value to the cardano ecosystem.

The Proposer is greatly concerned in providing all the details regarding understanding of the meetings, about subjects that meetings would cover, how many meetings can go into practice, who would  present each meeting, also about rewarding criteria, this even shows their ability to scale to address future challenges as well.

The proposal has presented clearly a short discussion on the potential risks and challenges that might occur during the development along with all possible solutions to overcome them.

Overall the impact of the proposal is high and fits in very well with the challenge and thus I strongly agree that this proposal effectively addresses the challenge.

It can be seen that you have prepared quite well for this project. You come up with some problems and solutions to those problems. You also created a Youtube channel to serve this project. I highly appreciate that. However, I think one thing that can stop you from making a successful project is how do you get people to join your talkshow? You've built a reward mechanism to incentivize elite community members to present about Cardano, but haven't built a solution to incentivize newcomers to the talkshow. This is a pretty important issue in most talk shows that take place in reality.

I am a Vietnamese so I fully support the Cardano talk for Vietnamese proposal in the Grow East Asia, Grow Cardano challenge. When I read the proposal, I found it sought to solve the problem of creating a community where Vietnamese people could stay up to date with news and have their questions answered about Cardano through the organization of weekly talkshows week. This is a challenge that has submitted a proposal at fund 8 but has not yet been funded, coming back to this fund 9, the authors have chosen to change the challenge to submit the project. I saw two significant changes to the proposal in the problem solving and funding sections of the proposal. If in fund 8, the authors still have shortcomings when they have not included solutions to solve challenges in the proposal, in fund 9 these problems have been fully supplemented and detailed from the author team, for the development of the Cardano community in East Asia in particular and the Cardano community in general. In the budget section, the change can be clearly seen as the amount applied for funding has been reduced by a third from 45 000$ in fund 8 to 15,000$ in fund 9. This shows me, in fund 9, the authors have made an overall recalculation for the proposal, added more content to make it easier for the community to understand the project, and adjusted the budget to apply for funding appropriately. I completely agree with the solution argument that the author team makes in the proposal. I myself have known Cardano for 2 years, it took me a lot of time to search for information about an problem online so more than anyone else, I really need a place with a lot of knowledge and information Cardano standards. It will save me a lot of time and effort for this job, and I also know that in Vietnam we, the Cardano community, although not yet accounted for the highest proportion, is still growing in popularity 2022 and beyond. They are all Cardano lovers and are very loyal to the ecosystem, in addition to that, a large number of people who are learning and ready to join the community show a need to find and exchange information the news about Cardano is huge. Both exchanging information and receiving rewards will give members more motivation, encourage them to actively seek, cultivate, refine information, participate and share their knowledge multiply them for the community. Because the impact of the proposal is so great, I will give the proposal 5 points in the hope that it will be funded at this 9 fund.

The “FIMI-Vietnamese Cardano Talk” recommendation fits the challenge setting perfectly. This proposal has not been funded at Fund 8. In Fund 9, there are 2 notable innovations of the proposal. First, the authors add an assessment of the impact of the Fimi Cardano talk show on three target groups: Fimi community members, on this challenge, and on the Cardano community. Second, the project budget is adjusted down from $45000 to $15000. I appreciate the team's effort to update and refresh the information. Here, the solution offered is to build a reward mechanism to incentivize elite members of the community to delve into Cardano. These members will then present to the community to make it easier for busy people and newbies to grasp new information about Cardano. The solution to create a Cardano Talk weekly is honestly not new. In fact, some Vietnamese community groups are also conducting weekly talk shows analyzing and discussing the potential of blockchain ecosystems. However, in the context of the crypto market's recent decline and accumulation, the Vietnamese community tends to invest more time in understanding potential ecosystems for a 2-3 year investment cycle. next. Therefore, I personally evaluate this moment, this is a necessary and timely solution. As a Vietnamese who has been involved in the blockchain industry for 2 years now, I agree and clearly feel the barriers that prevent Cardano from reaching the Vietnamese community that the team raised in the proposal. According to Chainalysis, Vietnam is a country with a special interest in blockchain, especially young people under the age of 30. In 2021, Vietnam ranks highest among 154 countries worldwide on the Crypto Acceptance Index (https://blog.chainalysis.com/reports/2021-global-crypto-adoption-index/) . The potential from the community is huge, still increasing, but we currently lack adequate, official, Vietnameseized resources to disseminate knowledge to a large number of people who love blockchain technology by Cardano. Although, nowadays there are a lot of information channels on the internet, small communities about Cardano also appear a lot on Facebook, Telegram… However, most of the information only focuses on short ADA trading opportunities. term. We lack in-depth, methodical, comprehensive information and analysis on the potential of the Cardano ecosystem. As a result, the community is not fully aware of the long-term investment opportunities with Cardano. This is why I agree with the authors' suggestions. The solution is generally useful for busy commuters. The risks outlined are exhaustive. So I rate 5 points on the impact of the proposal.

Cardano is a third generation decentralised proof of stake blockchain platform designed to be more efficient alternative to proof of work networks, scalability, interoperability and sustainability on proof of work networks like ethereum are limited by infrastructure burden of growing costs, energy use, and slow transaction times. Each development phase in cardano roadmap is anchored by research based framework, incorporating peer reviewed insights with evidence based methods to make progress and achieve use of application of blockchain network. To utilise the uses of Cardano people in Vietnam are expecting more talk shows as they can stay up to date with news of Cardano . Building a rewarding mechanism to motivate Vietnam people should be encouraged. This proposal effectively addresses the challenge and I agree with the proposal.

This proposal is exciting and suitable for this challenge. The Cardano and blockchain documents contain many technical words that are difficult to understand for newbies, as well as the English language barrier, so the team came up with a solution to build a reward mechanism to encourage members to learn. Cardano news and documents, then introduce them to the community. Topics will be explored and presented by groups through weekly talk shows to raise awareness among Vietnamese about Cardano. This solution is very viable to attract potential users and developers to join the ecosystem. The team also foresees the challenges and risks of undertaking this project, but they also offer solutions. The requested budget for this proposal is 15000 reasonable USD. With the success of the project, new entrants will gain knowledge about the Cardano ecosystem, creating a positive impact in the medium and long term.

This proposal effectively addresses the challenge as it focuses on the Vietnam community and which is one of the East Asia countries and it is a continuation of a previously funded proposal "Reward for Community Translators", which was during Fund 7. In the said proposal, the focus is to build a rewarding mechanism to encourage members to find news and documents about Cardano and then present it to the community. The team plans to have a weekly zoom session to highlight topics that the community is interested in and expand on them. Through their approach, ADA holders will better understand the advantages of Cardano blockchain technology to help them clearly see the VALUE of an asset they are investing in, instead of just seeing the UP-DOWN in price like another coin and kept up to date with the technological progressions made by the team of developers and the miraculous growth of the Catalyst development ecosystem, thereby helping them to have a strengthened belief in the future of Cardano. This indeed does help the community grow as a whole. If one understands more about the Cardano blockchain confidence follows, and this will lead to community growth in Vietnam. Leads to more potential users from word-of-mouth.

At this stage, Cardano ecosystem try to attract more users to reach the target one billion users over the world. This proposal not only improves the experience for existing users but also attract more new users in Vietnam. For my part, I agree with the proposer in that the rapidly increasing community size requires that documents and news about Cardano should be presented in a more timely and understandable way. There is no doubt about that language is one of the biggest barrier for those who want to learn more about Cardano blockchain in Vietnam. From my point of view, a large number of users in Vietnam realized that technical documents are really hard to understand, especially the newcomers. In contrast, elite members of the community can present it in a more understandable way to other users in the community.

Cardano users in Vietnam are increasing, they are looking forward to Cardano documents and news to learn about it. Your proposal has met the needs of the Cardano community by building a reward mechanism to encourage members to learn Cardano's news and documents, and then introduce it to the community. This solution achieves two goals, which is to help the community better understand Cardano and continue to develop the Cardano network in Vietnam. Your proposal has identified a possible risk that is the slippage of ADA and the demand of the community is too great, I think your explanation of how to reduce the risk is quite reasonable.

This is a good proposal to stimulate the community to learn and share to each other. I think the problem is articulated very clear and the key metrics and goals aligned with the outlined challenge settings. This project will surely add value to the Cardano ecosystem. One thing that I concern is about the risk section, I think the risk for this project isn't about slippage and too many topics, but the biggest risk is the frequency of the presentations (every week) and the credibility of the presentation. It is important to make sure that the shared material are correct and checked. With weekly presentation, it could be hard to check their accuracy of the material that they shared. It is important to collaborate with Cardano Vietnam Youtube channel. It is good to have this presentation at the official channel. I observed the channel too and I found that the video with the Vietnam language has way more views than English translated videos. I think it is better if the channel could have videos from local language.

The first is about the impact that is perfectly suited to the challenge. I appreciate your solution. Also, appreciate what you have done from previous funds through the channel systems that you have done. Prove that you have invested time and effort and are running this project with great enthusiasm and seriousness. And this solution is suitable in that the Cardano community in Vietnam or the blockchain community in Vietnam is very young and highly developed in Southeast Asia. Therefore, this is a market that should receive more attention and development. However, in the Vietnamese market in particular and the world market in general, investors are still having problems with the coins being inflated in price, causing the price to fluctuate quite a lot. Meanwhile, Cardano is a system that does everything with real quality and comes to life. Therefore, there is a need for Cardano's official information channels in Vietnam to be able to disseminate more information and investors to have more confidence to keep and continue to support the project. Help bring investors and developers of other projects to participate in Cardano's project more. Therefore, the impact of this project is very good, so it is rated 5 points. Now the solution of this project is also fine because some work have already been implemented and done very well. At the same time, you are doing very well with what they are saying. Therefore, the solution here is considered to be very good. It would be better if they added in the risk section, that there are other risks, for example, related to the accuracy of information. Because this part they will assign to Core team groups and some individuals to learn and present to the community, there should be an additional mechanism for content moderation before presenting to the community. To ensure the accuracy and clarity of information. To avoid possible deviations leading to the community being misunderstood during the presentation process as well as after uploading to youtube later for other members to follow.

Overall, this proposal is to create programs to update news and answer questions about Cardano for users, specifically here for Vietnamese people. This is an interesting and interesting area because Vietnam is currently one of the countries that can be said to be very open to blockchain and crypto, even very responsive information sources, precisely because The Cardano ecosystem is completely suitable for the Vietnamese community. In addition to creating Cardano update programs, the author will also build a reward mechanism to encourage members to learn Cardano news and documents, then introduce them to the community, this is an idea. good idea, attract users with rewards then give them access to knowledge.

This is an idea that perfectly fits the purpose of the challenge, which is to grow the community. I appreciate the fact that Fimi always regularly makes videos about the Cardano ecosystem, but I see that the channel has been built for a long time but has not yet attracted many users to exchange (or maybe as the author said, via Zoom) and the video is recorded and upload on youtube). And I also find the information provided by the author is very complete.

However, there is a small problem like this, this team has got the proposal of Fund 7, I have checked this information, and the budget of fund 7 is $18,000 with a roadmap of nearly 12 months, then between fund 7 and fund 9 is there any connection or difference? Fund 7 is a Reward for Community Translators, the budget plan for fund 7 is quite similar, it just differs in terms of the wording. I think the author should clarify this point. However, I still rate this as a project that perfectly fits the challenge's proposition. I'll give it 3 stars.

In my opinion, “Cardano Talk for Vietnamese” is a great idea and meets the challenge “Grow East Asia, Grow Cardano”. This proposal raised an issue that is quite concerned right now, that is: “Cardano users in Vietnam are looking forward to more talk shows so they can stay up to date with the news and get their questions answered about Cardano.” In recent years, the number of Vietnamese people using cryptocurrencies has increased. However, most people participate in the form of speculation, surfing rather than long-term investment, maybe part of the reason is that they do not have enough background knowledge and do not know the practical applications that the ecosystem has to offer Cardano brings. I am new to this ecosystem and have only been in crypto for 6 months. In the process of researching and learning more, I realized that for long-term development in this field, it is necessary to have a lot of knowledge, understanding, and a solid foundation to achieve the expected results. However, my limitation as well as many newbies often encounter is that I don't know where to start, or where to find the answers to questions, especially the biggest barrier is the language problem. I see that there are many problems if searching in Vietnamese will not work or the results will not be as expected. Searching in a common language like English will be much easier and more efficient. Therefore, language and time issues are difficult for us. Our difficulty is a matter of language and time. So creating weekly talk shows in the evenings to encourage people who want to dig deep into Cardano and then present it to the community to make it easier for busy people and newbies to access information about Cardano, is very meaningful and necessary. Besides, monitoring and absorbing information through talk shows, in addition to increasing knowledge and understanding, also help people to expand their relationships and meet and interact with more people. That will help a lot for newbies like me, instead of having to read and learn through dry, boring introductions or articles. With such positive effects, I think it makes sense to reward good and excellent presentations. The solution proposed by the proponent I find is also very clear and specific, through that solution, I can see the impact of the problem on FIMI community members, Vietnam, and the whole community of Cardano. To successfully implement the project, the proponent has also foreseen risks, that as Slippage of ADA price or because too many topics were requested from the community members. However, those risks are all prepared by the proponent to reduce risks. That helps the proponent to always proactively face difficulties. However, for talk shows to be attractive and interesting, in addition to excellent presenters, knowing how to attract listeners through how to lead the story, and knowing how to emphasize ideas for viewers to grasp ideas, the interaction between the presenter and the audience is also important. In my opinion, the proponent should have more exchange programs between the hours and the end of each talk show. Those exchanges can be decoding questions of which answers are keywords related to the talk show's content, or a minigame using 3-5 keywords to emphasize the main content just discussed through the talkshow. For those with good questions or excellent answers, there are rewards for them to encourage, and to let everyone capture the content without getting bored.

This proposal aims to further the knowledge of cardano in vietnam by creating a weekly talkshow to present technical help as well as general news about the cardano world, in vietnamese. This project have several interesting aspects that could help cardano's development in vietnam. First, the technical educational content in vietnamese will help both cardano-newbies and cardano-veterans contribute to the ecosystem in a more meaningful way, as their technical knowledge will be better. Secondly, this project has high potential to atract newcomers because of its interactive nature. Having 4 teams compete and be rewarded to present a project every week will push each team to do better and produce higher quality content. Having the community pick topics will ensure the topics stay relevant and about a topic that interests the users, making them more interested in learning. A disadvantage that I see in this project is how it is a telegram and youtube based community. There exists many well-respected telegram-youtube communities for vietnamese cardano users. It would be preferable to branch out and use other platforms to give more people access to information and reach a wider audience. Overall, I think it is a very good. project that will help develop the vietnamese cardano community.

• Surely we all know that now Cardano has been developing very strongly, the benefits and success of Cardano have been recognized by the Vietnamese community. However, nowadays Cardano users are looking forward to hosting more talk shows and providing knowledge and answers to questions about Cardano. With the idea of ​​CardanoTalk for Vietnamese people proposed by the topic, I find it a very good and useful idea.

  • Here the problem has been raised by the topic very specifically that is. Cardano users in Vietnam are looking forward to more chat shows where they can stay up to date with the news and get their questions answered about Cardano. I find the problem proposed by the topic well suited to the challenge. If the project is successful, it can scale up so that Cardano technology is more widely promoted, attracting potential consumers in the Vietnamese community and more developers to join the ecosystem.

  • In the solution section, the export topic has identified solutions to solve the above problem. Build a reward mechanism to encourage elite community members to dig deep into Cardano, then introduce it to the community to make it easier for busy people and newbies to grasp new information about Cardano. Talk shows will be held weekly in the evening time through the Meet Zoom program, lasting 2 hours. Then all meetings will be recorded and uploaded to FIMI youtube channel. I find the solution proposed by the group very suitable to solve the problem of the challenge with reasonable evidences and arguments as stated in the proposal.

  • Besides, the team has also foreseen the main risks that may be encountered in the project. ADA slippage, community members asking for too many threads. However, the group has also come up with a plan to reduce these risks in a very reasonable way. Ask for additional budget and choose only a few of the most important topics. I found the group's presentation to be very good and had no further comments.

Currently, the Vietnamese Cardano community is growing, however, there are not many resources for the community to update general information. Besides, one of the biggest obstacles for the Vietnamese community is the language barrier, Vietnam's score of 470 out of 700, put it in the low proficiency categrory Therefore, it is indeed difficult for Vietnamese to catch up internationally. FIMI is really a large and reputable organization in Vietnam with many years of experience in analyzed blockchain projects. The group's youtube channel has hundreds of video clips sharing information on all aspects of blockchain technology and Cardano. I agree with the author about the need to develop technology news and present it in a more interesting way that focuses on explaining and making technical words easier to understand. And to improve the interaction in the community, the idea of ​​encouraging good, experienced members to share knowledge is very good and deserves recognition. The reward mechanism for active contributors will promote community engagement and information exchange, enhancing confidence in the future of Cardano. I support your proposal and hope it will be funded.

The project's aim is to create well-prepared and high-quality talks to help people better understand cardano and to create a reward mechanism to make the information easier to get active by many good people. find out and bring it to the audience when participating in talks as well as watching videos the team also gave a website link related to this project (https://fimi.vn/ada,...), in terms of problems, they gave corresponding solutions to solve. , for the problems that prevent the project from succeeding, they have outlined measures to solve, but with the risks they pose, they should pay attention to how to attract listeners and create new ideas. really quality talk and pre-censor what they will say in the talk so that the listener understands exactly what the speakers want to convey.

Ideas are trying to address the region-specific approach of Cardano news in East Asia. With a reward mechanism to encourage core teams to give positive news to newbies and amateurs to capture accurate information. Personally, I find the team's idea very well suited to the challenge of F9: East Asian Development, Cardano Development. And the team also clearly presents the risks as well as governance to solve the project's problems. will meet mainly related to the price of ADA. I appreciate the team's constant effort as well as this idea.

With a reward mechanism for each correct information, to create a competitive mechanism. keep the group active to gain rewards as well as benefit the community. Personally, I think you have come up with a very convincing idea to help ADA holders better understand the advantages of Cardano blockchain technology to help them clearly see the VALUE of an asset they own. are investing, instead of just seeing the price UP-DOWN like other currencies. And regularly update specific news to reach the community in Vietnam for more sustainable development. The solutions are stated clearly enough. , explanatory examples accompanied by ideas.

A project. A very good idea for weekly talk shows to generate experiential knowledge for users who are interested and want to know the potential future value of Cardano Blockchain Technology application. The quick support tool helps users to master the information and analyze the topics related to cardano to some extent, helping to increase the experience for the review members. . Therefore, I believe it will contribute to the creation of elite members voting for the catalyst and dapps for the entire cardano blockchain ecosystem. I completely agree with this project proposal.

The proposal identifies the problem to raise vietnamese awareness of Cardano so that it can be applied to real life by 2022. It's a great idea to have a reward mechanism that encourages members to learn cardano's news and materials. The proposed solution has a clear impact on the cadano ecosystem. Talkshow is a good way to convey to me thereby raising the awareness of Vietnamese people about Cardano and can be applied to real life. The topic that you have come up with is practical for users to grasp what cardano is blockchain is. The solution to the challenge is appropriate. The implementation of the future expansion of the proposal is of interest, the implementation of the proposal shows us that it has met the learning needs of the Cardano community. The proposal presents risks in the implementation process in line with the problem, it is reasonable to offer a solution to supplement the required amount for the ADA slide for Fiat money. For topics that revolve around cardano/blockchain there is a lot of selection, ensuring priority over what is needed in the knowledge exchange in blockchain, this makes sense to solve the stated problem. Rating: 5

The problem is that Vietnamese users lack chat programs about the Cardano platform knowledge so they can stay up to date with news and answer questions. The solution to the problem is to organize 2-hour talk shows held weekly via meet zoom. Encourage members to participate by rewarding them for learning Cardano news and documents and sharing them with the community. The project is also in line with the goal of catalyst in fund 9. The project helps to develop the community, building a community willing and able to contribute to the development of Cardano.

"The problem described in this proposal fits the challenge. Vietnam is one of the countries with the largest population in the world, about 100 million people. Vietnamese people are very agile, flexible, and adventurous. With a young population that always welcomes technological improvements, a high percentage of people accessing the internet, and an increasing number of people owning smartphones, Vietnam is expected to become a country with a high adoption rate. get high with new technologies. This would be a great resource if there was a truly practical and effective platform like Cardano. However, basic information channels that are easy to understand for Vietnamese people to access are very few due to the complexity of this technology."

"It is seen here that the proposal of the project is very necessary. I appreciate the elaborate preparation of the core team. Readers can not only watch good videos in their familiar mother tongue but also listen to very intuitive explanations to help listeners easily grasp the information."

“The solution described in the proposal is to build core groups. Each group will develop a certain theme. Then, the best group will be selected, with a lot of good information and analysis to present. Through the reward mechanism to encourage the team to perform well. This is an effective solution to create competition among project teams. That will help the sharing sessions become more and more quality. However, it would be great if after those weekly sharing sessions there were collected evaluation information from the community, the quality of the sharing sessions would be more objective.”

"The way the proposed solution will help ADA scalpers in Vietnam will have a deeper understanding of what they are pursuing, so they will invest more sustainably. It should be repeated that the Vietnamese are very adventurous and most of the Vietnamese who know ADA are speculators. They will be the pioneers to popularize Cardano to more people in Vietnam. I am impressed with how the proposal addresses this challenge."

"The risk of ADA slippage and rambling on topics to share is always present. The hedging solution of the proposal I consider reasonable. However, it is also necessary to consider the risk of difficulty when conveying relatively complex content online.

The proposal was made to build a reward mechanism, encourage members to learn about Cardano, and then re-introduce it to the Community with the aim of helping busy people and newcomers to fully understand about Cardano easier. I think the proposal effectively addresses the challenge. The proposal raises the problem as follows: Cardano documents have appeared and existed a lot, but mainly the form given is text that sometimes the reader can not fully understand, need a channel interactive through oral presentation and interpretation, there is a reciprocal interaction between presenter and listener to create high efficiency in imparting knowledge about Cardano. This is one of the important issues in order to create people with knowledge about cryptocurrencies in Vietnam, because of many reasons that electronic money in Vietnam has not yet been widely developed and popularized. This proposal creates a knowledge base about Cardano and will have real effects in the development of Cardano in Vietnam. Two talk shows a week on topics around Cardano, while topics are prepared each session by the core team of the project. This forced the project to find a team with a lot of experience and knowledge about Cardano to bring quality to each talkshow. This is a small challenge that the project needs to overcome. The biggest impact of this challenge that the team needs to overcome is the expansion of Cardano to the community. Cardano blockchain technology is still a rather strange topic to Vietnamese people, so the solutions that the project offers are aimed at developing the Cardano community in Vietnam, including: providing knowledge and understanding about the Cardano community. Cardano is one of the core solutions today. The method of implementation through verbal interaction is a great advantage. I think the proposal outlines quite enough the specific impact on the Cardano community in Vietnam.

I found this recommendation to be a good fit for the ongoing issue of being updated with the news and having questions answered about Cardano. With this proposal, it will help those who already know Cardano to understand it more deeply, but there needs to be a good marketing strategy along with it to attract even those who do not know Cardano to participate. Example In Vietnam, people tend to go to cafes to work and relax a lot, this will be a place to help people know more about Cardano, so in addition to meeting via zoom, you can meet face-to-face. So, if this project is implemented, I think the team's proposal will be easy to implement because in Vietnam, coffee shops are also easy to do or meeting via zoom, almost everyone already knows how to use the software this soft.

Proposal to effectively solve the challenge. Cardano documents contain a lot of technical words, many users in Vietnam want more talk shows so they can stay up to date with news and get answers to their questions." Questions about Cardano The team has come up with a solution to build a reward mechanism to encourage members to learn Cardano's news and documents, then introduce it to the community. This is a solution to help new people, busy people easily absorb documents and news about Cardano. This solution will attract many potential users, and many developers to participate in Cardano's ecosystem.

Developing a talk show and rewarding the viewers is a great idea, where it will help people in clarifying their doubts in their native languages and as well as keeping people updated regarding changes that are involved in cardano in the current media. The drawback of the project is how long will the proposer can continue this project , how long can he update the people regarding latest cardano changes in the market , whether it will be permanent solution or just for temporary days ,other than that idea of rewarding is a great promotional touch to make this project work hence this proposal effectively addresses the challenge.

1. It is proposed to build a reward mechanism to encourage members to learn about Cardano's news and documents, then introduce them to the community. The problem is suitable for Challenge. Challenge's multi-question solving problem. The issue could expand in the future and add value to Cardano's ecosystem. Proposing to build a reward mechanism to encourage elite members of the community to learn deeply about Cardano and then present it to the community to make it easier for busy people and newbies to grasp new information about Cardano . The rapidly growing community size requires that Cardano documents and news be presented in a more timely and understandable manner. Technical information needs to be presented more interestingly. Translating the document is also difficult because the technical documentation about Cardano and blockchain contains many technical words that are difficult for newcomers to understand. Even translators with a high level of English fluency have difficulty achieving fluency, understanding, and closeness in their translations. The number of documents and news sometimes spikes (due to news related to government policy, Beartrap market, Bulltrap market, market crash…) so the number of full-time translators is not enough to meet demand. Although all documents have been translated and presented in written form, there is still a large number of community members who wish to hear a visually stimulating oral presentation. sense and can ask their questions and answers..The talk show will be held weekly in the evening time frame through the Meet Zoom program, lasting 2 hours. All meetings will be recorded and upload to youtube channel FIMI . Proposal has 4 core groups and will develop some more groups. Every week, any member of the community will propose a list of priority topics they are interested in and want to know about. Each core group will take on a topic on the list. Then, they will go together to find out information and analyze those topics. The core group with the best preparation with the most information will be selected to introduce to the community through a Zoom meeting. .There is a basic bonus for a Good presentation and a bonus for an excellent presentation. Topics to cover, here are some examples: Technical documentation (Hydra, sharding, smart contracts, UTXO …) Cardano update (Cardano 360, Hoskinson live video…).Market news.Strictly argued and relevant to the issue. Risk: Slippage of ADA. Sometimes ADA price drops suddenly, we can't sell ADA for USD or VND in time. This may leave us with insufficient budget to reward presenters and stakeholders.Risk: Community members request too many topics.Solution Requires 2000$ for backup and Select only the most important topics.I rate 5 point for this.

The proposal aligns with the challenge's objectives as it is a good proposition in guiding Vietnamese people to know more about Cardano. at the same time, build unique incentives on the incentive mechanism to encourage participants to learn about Cardano's documentary news and spread the word to the wider community. As a professional Cardano investment group, sharing knowledge about Cardano and the ecosystem is very easy to promote a lot of confidence for participants. Once we have made a project, we find that building a detailed plan is not enough to require new things, creating interesting attraction for the community. Providing concrete solutions such as building attractive mechanisms for elite members to learn about Cardano then to gain knowledge to present to others to understand valuable information about Cardano, accompanied by sessions The weekly talkshow is arranged at a suitable time and is recorded and uploaded to the group's own Youtube channels to save so that busy people can watch it again, which are plus points for this project, thoughtful. understand, put the position of others to plan carefully so that no one is left out. Topics are raised clearly and openly in this project. Worried about the risk that ADA fluctuates up and down and sometimes drops too low due to not being able to prepare transactions in time, so it is difficult to get enough capital to reward you solve it by making a temporary budget. For that to happen, it is inevitable that many participants will each have different ideas and requirements, but in this project, only important topics should be selected for implementation to avoid rambling and confusion.

The proposal is very interesting and will address a lot more people than before as we all know visual representation or hearing representation will have more impact on the individuals than just reading the texts or scripts. People might find it difficult to remember the concepts they read from the scripts whereas people tend to remember more when heard in a speech or a visual representation of the documents and this will enable a lot of new users in the cardano ecosystem as they will be doing Cardano talks in their local language i.e Vietnamese and this will provide an impact to a lot of local speaking people to gain more knowledge on Cardano. This is a very innovative idea to spread the knowledge of Cardano to a large number of users through speech which gives more impact. The proposal is scalable to future challenges as it can be implemented throughout the world in different language speeches and hence I agree the proposal has been effectively addressed.

Cardano seminars are an effective means of communication that should be widely adopted in different regions, not only in Asia. Vietnam has been conducting such live streams, but completely voluntary and without reward. This proposal is very practical, and a motivation for the talks to be better invested in quality and form. However, to spread to the community more, the proponent needs a mechanism for more participants to contribute content instead of just one presenter doing it. It is the facilitators who contribute content to the presenters who will better understand Cardano and will have the next layer of followers. I rate 5.

Here we have a solution to the need to obtain information in a fast, verified and understandable way for the Cardano community which, over time, is achieving a fast increase in its size, it explains that there is a lot of information that it is difficult to understand due to its technical language and the time it takes to get an accurate translation of it. Due to this, a reward mechanism is proposed so that qualified people are in charge of investigate and verify information and then delivering it to the community. The idea of informing the community to facilitate the entry of what many may consider a new world seems to be something that could add a lot of value, but something worring about that it is never indicated what the selection method of these will be. It would be great if they make this clear to have a better idea. However, it seems to be a proposal which can guide and help many people, progressing in the future. I rate the impact with 4.

I completely agree with the ideas presented in this proposal. It is proposed to build an incentive mechanism for members of Fimi's core team to research deeper into technology solutions and share what they learn with the community. This output fits perfectly with the "Grow East Asia, Grow Cardano" challenge given because it increases the participation of the Cardano community as well as Catalyst. Because today the source knowledge is heavily academic or in-depth knowledge that is difficult for a knowledgeable person to continue to acquire. Do that need a people or group who have enough to know the moistene sharing will back to the source of this knowledge in the simplest and easiest to understand style. Thereby helping to raise awareness of the Fimi community in particular and the Cardano community in general, contributing to increasing Cardano's coverage in the blockchain space.

This proposal is very much aligned with the challenge setting of Grow East Asia community, and very welcoming to grow in other countries in the region. The solution is the incentivizing mechanism for the quality team to find the quality content/research and present them to the community. This makes the content deliverers more accountable for what they share. The solution is very simple yet the impact is very huge for the beneficiaries, however, it requires the knowledge capability, and quality team members to deliver it. The voice of the community is truly taken into account with an individual member voicing up for the weekly topic, thus making the proposal really decentralized knowledge sharing. The risks are mentioned regarding the Ada price slippage that may affect the rewarding scheme. The over-requested topics are also well-covered and the team already thinking about prioritization. What could have been done better is the criteria flow for the topic selection and prioritization. Moreover, it is suggested that the core teams and presenters' selections should be more carefully mentioned as they are the keys to the proposal. It would be greater if the proposer can elaborate more on the process of recruiting/validating the core presenters.

This proposal very effectively addresses the challenge by providing original content in Vietnamese language and publishing the content to YouTube. The YouTube channel has an impressive amount of engagement and would be a benefit for Cardano to raise awareness in east Asia. The project team are all native Vietnamese speakers and are a good choice to lead this imitative. The proposal also funds a weekly zoom call among Vietnamese Cardano community members.

Cardano's brand awareness in Vietnam among crypto investors is still relatively low because many people do not understand Cardano and ADA well because the information they received is not official and most come from social networks and not be fact-checked. Therefore, this proposal contains an objective is organizing talk shows to update information about Cardano and answer investors' questions is an extremely urgent, useful, and valuable job for the community.

At the same time, the project also has a payment mechanism, which will attract Cardano experts to participate as speakers, increasing the quality of talk shows.

This proposal works on meeting Cardano users' quests of news and information and of deeper understanding of the Cardano ecosystem.

The means of achieving that involves encouraging members of the core teams with rewards. It also encourages the Cardano users to interact with the core teams weekly. Due to demands and the increasing news pieces, there is a need to recruit members to increase the number of core teams to meet the demands for research and translations of the information into Vietnamese. All this as I see it, involves getting members of the core team and the community at large to actively involve and contribute to the Cardano ecosystem aligned with the challenge settings.

I am not clear about how it would enlarge and expand the Cardano community as the proposal is not suggesting any marketing or promotion. However the successful implementation of the proposal and the weekly interactive activities coupled with the effort of producing good information, would also tend to promote and attract more Cardano users. For that reason I would rate a 4 for this setting, that I agree that this proposal effectively addresses the challenge.

The team of the proposal came up with a very good idea, the project matched the goal of the challenge. With the problem clearly identified, Cardano-made Vietnam users would love to have more chat shows where they can stay up to date with news and have their questions answered about Carano. This project solves some of the questions of the challenge, builds a reward mechanism to encourage members to learn about Cardano's news and documents, then introduces the community, through which suggestions can be found. can scale to solve future challenges and grow the Cardano ecosystem. talk about the solution of the proposal the team has identified the problem to be solved , the group also explains what will be done in each phase , very detailed and specific . talks about the risk that the team has identified Potentially can prevent the project from succeeding, the ADA price slippage, community members request too many topics, so the project owner also offers solutions to minimize the development and perfection of the project. .i think the proposal has high value and development . thank you

The proposal to solve the goal in the Challenge is East Asian growth and Cardano growth. The problem here is to create more chat programs so that Cardano users in Vietnam can stay up to date with news and answer questions about Cardano. This proposal directly adds value to the Cardano ecosystem. It is possible to gradually scale up and tackle future challenges. As more and more people know about Cardano, the opportunity to propose new ideas when building the ecosystem and working on the Cardano ecosystem increases. We can see the potential through proposals like these of Fimi, which is also a premise for continuing to build community and promoting Cardano blockchain adoption in Vietnam. Therefore, I have high hopes for this proposal and consider it a form of improving Vietnamese people's knowledge (knowledge of the Cardano blockchain). If this proposal is funded, it will be an incentive to encourage members to learn about Cardano news and documents and then introduce them to the community. I endorse the impact of this proposal because the great benefit it brings to the Cardano Vietnamese community is the world's first-class knowledge of blockchain technology. I rate it 5 stars.

This proposal seeks to build a rewarding mechanism to encourage members of their community to find out news and documents about Cardano and present them to the community. It is a laudable idea but the problem statement section is rather showing a solution, not a statement of a problem. The proposal seeks to encourage elite members of the community to get deep into Cardano to be able to present news and documents to the community to make it easier for busy people and newbies to grasp new information about Cardano. In addressing the challenge, the proposer has mentioned that this project will help community newbies to better understand the advantages of Cardano blockchain technology which is a goal of the challenge and also Fund9 objective. The proposal mentioned again that this idea will grow the Asian community and widely promote Cardano to potential users in the Vietnam community, and also get more developers involved in the ecosystem. The proposal has mentioned the risks associated with the project and mitigating measures, mentioning one of them is, too many topics requested from the community members and mitigating measure is to select the most important topic. Since the problem from the beginning is not precisely stated, but all other contents have addressed the challenge, I will give a rating of 4 for this section.

The Cardano community in Vietnam is one of the largest and growing communities. However, there are very few programs that share in-depth about Cardano and update new developments of the Cardano ecosystem. This makes it difficult for the community to update information due to the language barrier. Recommending CardanoTalk for Vietnamese is a good idea to help the Cardano community in Vietnam easily update regularly on Cardano developments, thereby helping the Cardano community in Vietnam grow stronger and stronger. again. Through sharing sessions like these, it can also give newcomers the opportunity to learn more about Cardano and participate in the Cardano system. This proposal perfectly fits the challenge presented.

A talk show is a great way to keep people informed about Cardano in na interesting way. It also is aligned with challenge as it directly addresses main challenge definition of success ("A broad spectrum of people across Asia and connected to Asia, coming together and forming teams to grow our ecosystem"), specially considering the size of vietnamese community interesting in Cardano. Proposer shows the value proposition in an articulated manner, showing the benefits for each stakeholder (Cardano, challenge and Fimi community members) The approach selected also seems innovative, by making people participate, as their topics of interest will be selected, and incentivizing elite members of the community to present this topic, with a reward mechanism. Some examples are also provided which helps to make the propject more tangible. As suggestions, this reward mechanism could be better explained here how the rate of good and excelent for the presentation will happen. A communication strategy would also be much welcomed, as it is essential that this talk show is properly advertised and reach the right people, for this proposal to have its full impact. These are just minor detials, though, and my rate is 5.

The problem is clearly defined in the proposal. Match this challenge item. Due to the language barrier, many Vietnamese Devs have difficulty accessing Catalyst. The project was born to train Vietnamese developers to join Catalyst. The problem here meets one of the essential requirements of the challenge. Engage developers from outside the existing community to participate in Catalyst. Hand in hand, guide developers with ideas to write proposals on Catalyst professionally, on the right topic.

Help DRep evaluate proposed projects on Catalyst, raise capital from Catalyst to operate and develop their projects. The scope of influence on the 1-language community. Scope of influence and development in Vietnam. The target group of users is the Blockchain-loving community in general and Catalyst in particular. The project is scalable beyond the Cardano ecosystem.

About the product of the project, Products are live sessions, live talks, youtube videos, and zoom group meetings, with direct interaction between experts, the core team, and members of the Fimi community. Proposal to add value to the Cardano ecosystem. Specifically, the CatalystTalk product makes it possible for an amateur developer to know how to write a proposal or, to evaluate a project, to propose on Catalyst. By participating in talks and sharing about Catalyst. Attract developers to participate and contribute their products to the development of the Cardano ecosystem. They are increasing the number of participants in Catalyst, and improving the quality of reviews of proposals.

"This is a follow-up to a project that has been funded since the previous round, here is the idea as well as a request from the community for the previous proposal to compile progress updates and information. The development of the Cardano platform, especially the live videos of CEO Charles Hoskinson about the progress updates on Cardano's technology in progress, along with the proposal has expanded and improved further by addition of videos with in-depth analysis on terms or a feature of the protocol that Cardano is developing, especially the past and upcoming eras, the upgrades will provide additional features. What functions and protocols and a lot of things need to be analyzed and clarified about the technology for the community to gain useful knowledge, and at the same time firmly believe in the technologies that Cardano is developing for investors. owned by the original ADA.This proposal is developed to target all Vietnamese citizens. am, and the colony of Southeast Asia, so the proposal is a perfect fit for the requirements of the challenge. *this is a great community development idea, with a solid foundation and reputation, the group has a great influence on the Vietnamese community, so this proposal will be an expanded affirmation communities across the country, and also leverages future developers in the region to gain knowledge from the proposal, then contribute great proposals to the Catalyst ecosystem. with the self-sufficient model from the community is to take the knowledge and information available at IOHK to spread them to the community, and this work will be done by an elite group of members from the community, so the risk The risk to this proposal is almost nonexistent, and the only problem we are seeing is the network drop of the ADA coin, which will affect the value and projected spending of the originally intended goals. Initially, however, the proposed team had a plan to apply for more for this provision. * However, in the matter of hedging for the reserve fund, in my opinion, the group needs to explain more or declare that ""if during the implementation process, the reserve requirement is not used because it is possible that the ADA price will increased in that time, what will the money be used for? example might be adding to the budget for later round development expansions"", "

When analyzing the proposal, at first we came across ideas that were already widely used by other projects, which makes us have a little doubt if the idea in question would have enough impact, or would be just more of the same. However, unlike other projects, we were able to find here a great background that helps FIMI to differentiate itself, both for the professionals involved and for the activities already established. With this, it is possible to believe in good chances of this project positively impacting the Cardano ecosystem in the medium and long term, as well as disseminating education and knowledge about blockchain in the Asian continent. With this we can say the proposal fits perfectly in the metrics of the challenge. Furthermore, given the activities that will be completed and the total time of these activities, we have that the amount being requested seems correct.