The concept of bringing education and games together is surely gonna catch quite a lot of users' attention. A lot of proposal plan to engage users in pure gaming scenarios and a lot of proposals in the other challenges tries to bring a lot of educational content onto the chain through the traditional approach, which could end up boring a lot of people. This proposal, however, plans to mix them both by picking the exciting essences from them. Involving the users through hackathons, quizzes, games and binding them attractive incentives like tokens will surely draw a lot of "nerd" gamers onboard and also help Cardano's gamer community a lot more diverse and powerful. Konma also mentions having an existing 2-D multiverse platform to keep the users engaged and plans to involve a lot of institutions which can draw a lot of young minds into the ecosystem thus triggering a lot of future contributions. The team is also aware of the possible hurdles they might have to cross during their quest and also have reliable solutions for them.

Developer has a concept for people to learn through a game that encourages engagement and rewards them with NFTs, including an NFT certification upon completion. This seems like an excellent idea and furthers the future of Cardano and the industry.

With this proposal, the focus is about bringing a massive change in Gamified education and learning to make education affordable to connect with real world use cases. Simply, the proposer wants to disrupt the traditional education system. With the impact of this proposal, Konma wants to break education boredom by the introduction of new technologies across education, trading, etc. for every individual to upskill while playing; educating community members while they get rewards in various ways across eCommerce stores, jobs, etc; a gamified learning management system. In addressing the challenge, Konma Upskill addresses educationin general with regard to educating users across the globe and increasing awareness of the importance of getting upskill through a gamified learning management system. The stated risks are in development(small terms), user retention, incentivizing, and credibility. The proposer provided a solution to these challenges such as building a platform for users to grow relationships among themselves for better collaboration, seeking continuous advice from Cardano community, and opportunities to users, among others. In my opinion, the challenge is effectively addressed. My rating is 4.

Yes this proposal does effectively address the challenge with the aspect of bring new gamers into the world of Cardano. I wish it was more clear on the target group that it plans on bringing in. This seems like a great ideal but Im not entirely sure if its fit for the Gamers on - chained challenge

This is a good proposal and unique.I followed the shared link (https://linktr.ee/konma) to test the Konmi Metaverse.I love the fact that it can be tested as an anonymous user and i got lost playing around the office virtual environment on the konmi servers.It has an addictive potential and everything works. This proposal will positively increase the use of cardano and also its popularity if fully adopted and i am giving 5 star. Note to the proposer: It is necessary i correct some assumption especially on the impact section of the proposal.

• I think addressing education in the proposal is kinda broad because various regions have different education system and i do not believe you have experienced all the education systems in the world to know which is best especially if you factor in societal norms.
• it is crucial to understand that you cannot use a blanket method for learning due to different societies and cultures.This is because society and culture is what births the mode of learning.
• What happens to learning before the gaming phase (Learning before the individual gets to the age to play games)? what if the initial learning prohibits gaming (Assuming the individual is raised by some fictional zealots that are opposed to education?).

This is a great video by Michael Seibel and Dalton Caldwell about changing the little things that might interest you https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnav9vgHDHs I understand you are sprinting development but making avatars, games, protocols, dashboard, rules, steps between 1-2 months is kinda too small speaking from my personal experience as a game developer(considering you are gamifying education). I also think incorporating game theory techniques will help this system (I believe the hired professional will suggest this).

Developers have set goals to create an educational gaming system. They specify they will maintain timelines and regular updates to track their progress. There should be sufficient opportunity to audit this project easily.

Konma has been a name that's been around previous funding rounds and they have been appreciated many times prior and I feel the team would make sure the audit process is effortless in every way possible. The team makes a brief promise about them making timelines and milestones that adhere to the challenge's requisites. However, the team makes no mention of valid KPIs to assist the community in the audit process. There is no evident way to make sure that the progress is well within the expectations of the challenge. A few metrics upfront that the auditors could look forward to would have done a great deal for the proposal. However, the success metrics and the final goals the team intends to achieve look promising and impactful. The one-stop platform of all kinds of learning and cross-chain attribute is surely something to look forward to. The project being an entirely new one, a little more sustainable metrics would had tipped the scale in their favor.

The set timeline, stakeholders, project assignments, brainstorm sessions, etc. all in weekly and monthly planning will make auditing easy and effective. The proposers are already at a stage of gathering virtual space for the community and taking a step by step approach to gradually gamify their entire Konma Syatem for all DAOs. To see the success of this proposal, there would be access to the platform of new innovative methods of learning technology; the platform grows by itself with word of mouth, etc. This is a new proposal. I agree that the information provided is sufficient for successful auditing. My rating is 4.

mentioned clickup but proposal fails to explain what it (Clickup) does or share a link(https://clickup.com/) to assist CA to look it up. Will the click up links be shared with the community to follow the project? I looked up ClickUp and it can be used to track projects well therefore as long as links are shared to the cardano community, this proposal can be audited . I will be taking away 1 star as this is a vital information for this category and was missed. I wish to give 5 star but it will be unfair to the CA guidelines the information in this section was not communicated well (especially as an educator). i am giving 4 stars. I wish the team good luck with this project, cheers.

The proposal lays out a well detailed plan of the goals and timeline for the project to deliver the solution. It beaks down how they will allocate the funding for this project, not only into a time line but also into direct usage. Making it clear what will be spent and how. This will help make it easy to audit the progress and success of the proposal.