This proposed solution, without a doubt, is a necessity for the dApps ecosystem in Cardano. With the usage of WalletConnect, now any dev, dApp, or builder on Cardano can increase their chance of being successful because of the access to a bigger potential user base. Moreover, the team intends to make developers' life easier by giving them the power to transit from Ethereum to Cardono without losing any small percentage of their user base, which can be considered a crucial and essential feature. The stake board explains and gives out a comprehensive target and vision, from which we can clearly see how this project can make a great impact on the Cardano ecosystem. To sum up, I truly believe that this solution can greatly reduce the stress of developers as well as make dApps built on Cardono access to a higher chance of success.

To be honest, this is one of the most brilliant proposals I have ever seen in this forum. Metamask is well-known and can be considered the most popular Web3 wallet now. However, there is no easy, plug-and-play way for Cardano dApps. Now thanks to the implementation of Walletconnect, instead of focusing on the connection between Meta mask and Cardano, developers can zero in on building a better dApp. Moreover, when the access to 100x more wallets and 15x more monthly active wallets is at hands, the advantages the proposal can bring to the table is unmatched. All vital steps are break down into small, achievable pieces so that supporters can keep track on them and all main risks that can inhibit the success of the proposal are thoroughly identified. After all, the diffusion of WalletConnect will have immense positive impact on dApps as well as developers.

The influence this proposal could have on the dApps ecosystem is immense. Involvement of the MetaMask integration along with the project will bring confidence amongst the locals and improve the adoption of Cardano for dApps applications. This proposal will bring more traffic to the ecosystem and solidity to its capabilities overall. With the influence the proposal leaves, it will set off the spread of Cardano across various blockchain ecosystems. Currently the majority of the community is concentrated in ETH projects throughout the world that we can then piggyback off of quickly.

The proposal clearly addresses the objectives laid out in the challenge. It wants to empower the cardano dapps and the developer community to convert more ETH into ADA using metamask. Cardano doesn’t have an open source plug for that reason they can’t merge with their website and this makes it difficult for many people. Imagine merging metamask and cardano, this will bring more people into the cardano community since they will be able to receive or send using ETH.

Metamask is one of the largest crypto wallets for Etherium in terms of users, and this proposal will integrate Metamask with Cardano. This proposal is great for the developer ecosystem, since many Web3 developers would find metamask integration, with its active users, valuable. As the proposal says: "Open-Source Metamask & Cardano integration allows 55 million monthly active wallets to easily send, receive, and drive adoption & traction on Cardano dApps and projects to accept ETH and receive ₳DA."

Cardant is part of a wider crypto space that is lead by ETH and BTC. MetaMask is a ETH wallet that is used by millions to run Dapps over ETH/BNB/Polygon and many other L1 / L2 chains. The Proposal is mainly to offer the porting of Cardano and allow MetaMask to send and receive ADA also use Cardano Dapps that have recently started in early 2021/2022. The fact that it is possible to register an ADA wallet on MetaMask is a great achievement and may help grow cardano. In addition there are various Dapps that are growing on cardano and more specifically DEXs reaching record TVL. Having access to the mainstream wallet of MetaMask is a great idea as many have started to to switch from ETH to other L2 chains and even BNB or other L1 that operate on MetaMask. The high fees on other chains and the security of cardnao might help sway more users to cardano. In addition the NFT space will also grow on cardano if MetaMask operates which can help OpenSea and other ETH NFT markets to list Candano NFTs.

Its a great idea to start off with, As proposer tells MetaMask is most popular and widely used wallet, there are various other proposal which address similar idea of MetaMask and Cardano wallet integration, All of them trying to achieve a same or similar goal which should be completed for more efficiency in Cardano eco system. As proposer addresses Currently cardano Dapps lack effortless and open source plug-ins which can be added easilsy on any websites to receive, send, and fund user activities using ETH. By making sure it can be added it will make sure Cardano can be sent or received everywer easily. As challenge would get more 55million new wallets after integration and challenge does not face much risk to Cardano. Here proposer effectively addresses the challenge.

This proposal seeks funding for the development of Open-Source Metamaskand many other wallets & Cardano integration using WalletConnect. The problem is clear, there is no open-source plug-in for the Cardano dapps to use with Meta mask wallet. The impact of this proposal is unquestionable. Meta mask with 55M monthly active users could bring fast adoption to Cardano. This proposal is clearly in line with the challenge goals and metrics. I strongly agree that this proposal effectively addresses the challenge.

A solution is needed for Cardano dApps and projects to reach over 300 million crypto users worldwide. WalletConnect is a universal protocol to facilitate a secure connection between any wallet and any dApp. Thanks to WalletConnect, users can interact with any dApp using their favorite wallet. Developers only need to worry about developing the best of their product. Successfully implemented OpenSource MetaMask proposal<=>₳ Integration will make Cardano projects and dApps accessible to more than 300 million crypto users. In addition, it also helps Cardano projects and dApps interact with 100 e-wallets, especially Metamask, and reach more than 55 million users today on WalletConnect. This will help the Cardano ecosystem to grow even more.

A short explanation of the proposal: a bridge between apps and wallets. The current integration being between metamask and dapps in the cardano ecosystem. This is an awesome idea with quite a few prospects. It's sure to bring many people in the ada ecosystem, because metamask is one of the most used and easily accesible wallets in the whole crypto ecosystem. It's widely used which makes it a perfect target for integrations. The proposal gives many valid arguments as to the impact it will bring and the users it will get. This is one of the most thourough projects being detailed, well structured and percise. Currently I don't see anything missing in this proposal and I have no worries as an assessor for 4 funds running or a developer. The proposers have mentioned some valid risks alongside solutions or at least methodology for overcomming them. Scaling shouldn't be an issue, keeping in mind the multiple integration projects already done with Wallet Connect. Overall an impactfull and elegant solution, that I hope gets funded and widely adopted. I give it the maximum score.

I strongly agree that this proposal effectively addresses the challenge. The proposal proposes Open-source Metamask and Cardano integration via WalletConnect, which is a generalized protocol that facilitates dApp and wallet integration across chains.

However, WalletConnect so far does not support Cardano dApps, but has support for many other dApps on different chains such as BSC and Ethereum. This proposal wants to build an open source integration between Cardano dApps and MetaMask wallet, thereby opening doors to a huge number of new wallets and Ethereum users who are not pleased with gas fees and/or would like to utilize low transaction fees on Cardano.

The impact section clearly also describes how the proposal directly improves developer experience and also increases user adoption via helping them to move to Cardano blockchain from EVM based chains.

Yes. This is one of the most straightforward proposals to address this challenge. The developer base in general will benefit directly from bringing this project to term, by making the new dapps directly interoperable with other blockchains. This is the example of a key piece of infrastructure bringing massive benefits to the ecosystem.

I must say that the auditability was really well done by the proposers. Not only any supporter can give their feedback from Snabrillia Demo and Town Halls, a virtual event that the team host to have a chat with the community, but also every important key metric and KPI are thoroughly given out. The proposal’s makers are experienced and have been around in the tech industry long enough to understand what they have to face in the way to achieve their target; hence, their description of issues, their solutions, and their expected results are precisely and concisely presented, in a way that supporters can easily understand and follow the developing process. The quality of this proposal’s auditability is unmatched.

I must say that the clarity of the road map and how carefully it is constructed by the team can enable supporters to easily keep track on the progress. Especially, OpenSource MetaMask<=>₳ Integration will be open-source on Github, so that everyone can check up on the project at any time. From what I see, all key daily metrics and KPIs are identified to ensure the success in the developmental progress. What I love more is that once to twice a month, the proposers will host a Snapbrilia Demo and Progress After Town halls, where everyone can give feedback and play an important role in the achievability of the proposal.

A roadmap with clear deliverables, milestones, and timeframes are provided in the proposal. Success indicators will be measurable due to the statistical nature of the work. By reading through the proposal, the team aims to share the results and process via bi-weekly town halls and other channels, where many community members visit. When the proposal gets funded, it might lead quite a few new people to attend these town halls after understanding the impact of this proposal. I like that the team will provide the final build as an open-source project for everyone to use. This team shows a deep understanding of potential challenges by having a perspective on the past, present, and future development of the Dapp ecosystem. All in all, I firmly agree that this proposal provides me with adequate information to assess the progress in achieving its stated goals.

There is clarity in the description of the problem, the solution and how the proposal is aligned with them. Relevant links are given and the roadmap is well designed, there are milestones that make auditing the proposal easier. The KPIs are well chosen and I think they are good indicators for evaluating success.

The project is very auditable. First, the project will be open-source on Github where anyone can measure its progress by the projected milestones. And then there are several kpi's including the number of wallets and connected and active wallets connected to this integration, and number of dApps and projects using this integration. Snapbrillia also hosts monthly townhall meetings to provide updates to milestones.

The team listed many deliverable and communication plan to keep the progress tracked. They also have placed their efforts to post the work in open source. The GitHub will be the main recourse to track the finalized items. Part of their deliverable is to onboard MetaMask users which will show an impact on the mainstream media and make the news which is an exciting aspect of this project

The details that already given is satisfactory, I feel proposer can provide verifiable metrics than the usual achieving milestone KPIs timely, As project is seperated in stages it can be easily auditable without much efforts, As success of projects will ease process of converting ETH to ADA will help Cardano Ecosystem and bring more users, As idea i feel is better than similar proposals still it will be very helpful for longterm view, This proposal can be supported by various other proposals all working towards a common goal making the proposal all the more virtuous and dependable. Hence, the provided KPIs are plenty and apt for easy monitoring of the implementation and the overall success. As proposal will empower Cardano by converting ETH to ADA and Fund requested also sensible, I would likely want this proposal to be funded and voted.

• The proposed implementation roadmap from Q3/2022 – Q1/2023 was presented in a very detailed and clear manner by the team. This shows the professionalism in the way the team works. In addition, the budget amount of $92,000 is clearly and transparently used by the team. However, I have a small suggestion for you that you need to be more detailed about your expenses in order to receive higher approval from the community. Example: Cloud Storage & ETH and Cardano Transaction Fees: $20,000.00. This expense needs more detail from you. The KPIs given by you are also very clear and complete. I believe that the community will also appreciate you very much.

Great KPIs covering a large portion of all adoption monitoring possibilities. Reasonable measurable, realistic metrics and KPIs. I don't see any problems for anyone to follow the progress of this proposal to it's fruition. I really like the deffinition of success and the clear vision and mission of snapbrilla. I remember reviewing other proposals they've had and they keep getting better and better. They keep growing the channels to grow their community organically and by the looks of it, it's working. I wish the best of luck to the proposers and keep up the good work!

The KPIs/success metrics are explained and it can directly be measured against each other, not only at the end of the proposal but also during the implementation phase. The KPIs are the number of dApps and Projects, wallets using the integration, active wallets, and the monthly transaction volume flowing through the integration this proposal proposes.

Roadmap with milestones is detailed out based on the features and integrations with different Charli3, Milkomeda, Metamask WalletConnect are provided and progress of them are measured daily based on the deadlines vs proposal progress, story points (sprint backlog), Date of Deployment to dev/staging/production environments. Therefore, I strongly agree. Good luck to the team for this proposal.

Yes. Besides having some well defined KPI´s, the team has always been transparent, having a space after Town Hall meetings to present the progress on their projects and answer questions made by the community. The success is very easy to gauge, since they are targeting interoperability between ETH and Cardano via the Metamask wallet. You cannot ask for a more well-known reference. If succesfull, the bridge from Metamask to Cardano will be open, and assets will be able to flow one way or the other. This tackles exactly not only the challenge, but a day-to-day utility feature we are lacking.