I think the team is perfectly capable of developing or improving on CIP8 to meet their own needs. So, from a feasibility standpoint, I think it is very feasible. I just wish there would have been a broader discussion of the overall benefits of enhancing the existing specification I some more educational discussion on why the current specification is not in a usable state. My issue is that this proposal seems rushed and does not give the reader much context on very complex topic. I am pretty familiar with generic protocols like http, ftp, html, xml, xls. xmtp etc that are used in web2. I think the proposer should have taken the time to explain in more detail. Example from the CIP8 Spec: “Private keys can be used to sign arbitrary data. If you have the public key, you can verify the data was signed by the owner of the private key. This is how transaction signing works internally but its utility is not limited to transactions.” For this reason, I give this proposal a score of 3 of 5 for Feasibility.

The team seems to be familiar with the original CIP8 message signing specification, so they should be ideally positioned to deliver an improved version. Timeline isn’t really a consideration from my side - the important thing is to get the job done in a safe and secure manner - critical when we’re talking about infrastructure pieces. I would have loved to see a part of the budget set aside for formal verification / third party audit or something similar but that does not seem to be the case. One star subtracted that for four stars in the end for feasibility.

The feasibility of the project seems reasonable, primarily because the proposal comes from dcSpark, a well-known and reputable company in the Cardano ecosystem with a track record of delivering on Catalyst proposals. The fact that dcSpark has authored the original Cardano message signing specification (CIP8) adds to their credibility in implementing this new layer for auto-signing.

The main goals of the project, which include completing the specification, reaching consensus on it, and announcing its integration into at least one wallet, are clear and achievable. Moreover, the project's timeline appears feasible, given the straightforward nature of the tasks.

The proposal, however, lacks a more detailed plan for implementation, including how other wallets and dApps will be encouraged to adopt this new standard. The success of the project will largely depend on widespread integration and adoption. It would be helpful to have more information on how the team plans to promote and support the adoption of the auto-signing system.

This implementation plan provides an overview of the project implementation steps, however, it is not detailed enough to ensure that the activities and tasks are carried out fully and effectively. This requires the proposal writer to add more detailed information to ensure the feasibility and success of the project.

Proposal writers may lack detailed explanations or rationale for proposed expenses. In my opinion, the writer of the proposal should provide clearer explanations to help stakeholders better understand why and how to use finance to perform tasks.

This is an excellent team. They are a team with the in-depth knowledge and in-depth skills to professionally and efficiently execute the project that the proposal requires. They have proof and credentials of previous experience and obvious success in similar projects. However as always they do not provide much information about this.

With the information they provide I only rate 4 stars for feasibility.

It is proposed to provide a solution to build a secure standard for message signing without notification from crypto wallets. This solution will help solve the problem of using crypto wallets in cases where frequent message signing is required, which will improve the user experience when interacting with web3 dApps.

The solution addresses the challenge of the challenge by focusing on improving the user experience and increasing flexibility in the use of cryptocurrency wallets.

The audience that this solution will serve is the users in the Cardano ecosystem, especially those who need to sign messages frequently such as in dApps, daily transactions, and other activities on the blockchain.

For me as a regular user of dApps, signing messages without notification from the e-wallet might result in a better experience. But the problem here will reduce the security of the wallet and make it easy for bad guys to exploit. The proposed solution has a certain impact, but they will face many difficulties in solving technical problems to improve security. I rate 4 stars for impact

Here’s an easy case here. Sebastien Guillemot (well known figure in the community) and DCSpark (same) propose to improve the message signing specifications through an additional layer that allows wallets to auto sign messages under safe circumstances. Apparently there has been a lot of growth in message signing and this feature would be very nice to have. Sebastian and DCSpark are a strong badge of seriousness in the Community, and I would tend to vote with them on this one - rating their proposal as a five star for impact.

The proposed sollution aims to addrress the challenge of tedious messsage signing in the crypto ecosystem, especially in use-cases involving NFTs and gaming. By creating a new layer on top of the message signing system, the project seeks to enable wallets to auto-sign messages safely when appropriate, making the process more user-friendly. This improved user experience is expected to benefit the Cardano ecosystem significantly, especially for web3 games that rely heavily on message signing.

The project's potential positive impact lies in its ability to enhance user retention for web3 games, leading to increased traffic and adoption. As NFTs and gaming are among the most prominent use-cases for blockchains, an improved gaming experience can attract more users, thereby contributing to increased transaction volume on the Cardano blockchain. Additionally, making web3 games more viable as a business model can encourage more companies and individuals to launch games within the Cardano ecosystem, fostering growth and expansion.

, the proposal lacks specific details on how the auto-signing system will be integrated into wallets and dApps, which makes it difficult to fully evaluate the potential impact. Nevertheless, the concept itself has the potential to positively influence the user experience in the Cardano ecosystem.

Cải thiện trải nghiệm người dùng: Dự án sẽ giúp cải thiện trải nghiệm người dùng bằng cách làm cho việc ký tin nhắn dễ dàng và thuận tiện hơn. Điều này sẽ làm cho blockchain dễ dàng tiếp cận hơn đối với nhiều người hơn và có thể dẫn đến sự gia tăng trưởng về mức độ chấp nhận. Tăng cường bảo mật: Dự án sẽ giúp tăng cường bảo mật bằng cách giảm nhu cầu người dùng nhập lại khóa cá nhân của mỗi người khi họ cần ký tin nhắn. Điều này sẽ giúp giảm nguy cơ bị tấn công và có thể giúp bảo vệ người dùng khỏi bị mất tiền. Mở rộng khả năng sử dụng: Dự án sẽ giúp mở rộng khả năng sử dụng của blockchain bằng cách cho phép các ứng dụng dApp sử dụng ký tự tin nhắn mà không cần nhắc ví. Điều này sẽ cho phép các nhà phát triển tạo ra nhiều loại ứng dụng mới và sáng tạo hơn trên blockchain. Tăng cường khả năng tương tác: Dự án sẽ giúp tăng cường khả năng tương tác của blockchain bằng cách cung cấp một cách tiêu chuẩn để ký tin nhắn. Điều này sẽ cho phép các ứng dụng dApp giao tiếp với nhau một cách dễ dàng hơn và có thể dẫn đến sự phát triển của các hệ sinh thái dApp lớn hơn và mạnh mẽ hơn. Dự án này đã được chứng minh rõ ràng trong tất cả các khía cạnh của đề xuất rằng nó sẽ có tác động tích cực đến hệ thống sinh thái Cardano. Dự án đã được thực hiện bởi một nhóm các nhà phát triển có kinh nghiệm và có uy tín, và nó đã được thử nghiệm và đánh giá kỹ thuật. Dự án cũng đã nhận được sự hỗ trợ của cộng đồng Cardano và nó đã được tích hợp vào một số ví Cardano.

Dự án này có tiềm năng là một đóng góp có giá trị cho hệ thống sinh thái Cardano. Nó sẽ giúp cải thiện trải nghiệm người dùng, tăng cường bảo mật, mở rộng khả năng sử dụng và tăng cường khả năng tương tác của blockchain.

This proposal seems a bit rushed to me and also a bit self-serving for Paima. But it still could have an impact Cardano and other developers. A strong messaging protocol would be very helpful for Dapps to talk to one another as well as wallets and Dapps. This proposal is just to develop a specification, but I did not see much about how other community members could be involved in writing the Spec. I looked and CIP8 and could not figure out what improvements are being proposed. Is the CIP8 lacking in some way? This feels like an add on to the spec that would benefit Paima, which is cool, but what about other Dapps, wallets etc? Its coming from an experienced team so I am sur it would have impact on their gaming platform. I just wish I could have seen more detail on how it could benefit other applications in the Cardano ecosystem. So, this reason I give this proposal a score of 3 out of 5.