"it sounds like you have a well thought out plan for each milestone, with clear outputs and expected outcomes. I would like to emphasize a few important points:

1. You plan to secure a venue for the ""Blockchain EXPO Fall"" event by August 2023 at the latest. This is an important milestone and should be prioritized so that you can proceed with your planning activities. other.
2. By September 2023, you plan to start planning promotional materials and exhibitions for the ""Blockchain EXPO fall"" event. This is a good time frame to start this task, as you will need time to research, design, and implement.
3. The estimated time for the implementation of the planned activities and results is realistic. It looks like you've timed each milestone and taken into account possible interruptions or delays.
4. It is important to regularly monitor your progress, assess any deviations from the plan, and communicate any changes or challenges to stakeholders. This will help ensure that you stay on track and can make any necessary adjustments to achieve your goals.
5. Overall, it looks like your project has a solid foundation and a solid plan. With hard work and dedication, I believe you can make this project a success. I wish you all the best in your endeavours.

"

The proposer has successfully organized similar exhibitions before so I think they can carry out this project successfully without any difficulty. However, I recommend the proposer to add more information about the team members so that the voter can easily assess the ability of each member. For example, contact information, skills, experience and roles of members.

They work hard and help the Cardano community to make it better and stronger. I think the Cardano community trusts and likes them.

They know how to make good events and do them well. They also show that they are honest and careful with their money and work.

They want more people in Japan to know and use Cardano, which is a big and important place for web3 things. They also want more people to make and use things with Cardano, which is good for Cardano and its users. They also want Cardano to be the best choice for making and using things, which is better than other platforms.

I think they have a smart and good way to do their goals. They will show Cardano at big events and other places to make more people see and like it. They will also tell and show people how good and useful Cardano is, like how it uses science, research, green energy, and smart contracts. They will also help and ask people to join and work with Cardano.

They will check and tell how well they are doing their things, like how many people come, take, ask, get, see, join, download, meet, and make ideas. They will also share their work and results with the Cardano community in different ways, like monthly reports, meetups, and social media. They plan to show Cardano at two big events in Japan, one in autumn 2023 and one in spring 2024. They also plan to show Cardano at other web3 places in the year. They have said what they will do for each event, like getting the place, making the papers and things to show, showing and counting the people, and helping and working with the people.

They have also thought about the things that may change or be hard for their project, like the places, the people, the events, and the Covid-19 thing. They have also said that they will choose the best events and places to show Cardano after they do more research.

I think your plan is useful and easy to understand. It also helps the Cardano community to know and follow your work and results.

The proposer possesses experience in conducting exhibitions for Cardano, which makes the project feasible for successful implementation. Additionally, the proposer has involved some of the most prominent figures in Cardano, including Sebastien Guillemot from dcspark and Yuri Kuriyama from jpg.store, among others. Since the project is an offline exhibition, it will be straightforward for the community to verify its execution. The proposal also provides measurable metrics to define the proposal's success, such as the number of visitors, participating companies, and involvement in Cardano. The publication plan for the project is clearly outlined, with intentions to publish in the Cardano forum, as they have done in the past, and on social networking sites. The feasibility section is excellently written, and considering the team's experience, the project is highly likely to be successful.

In such way that the idea is great and have positive impact to the community, the feasibility of the project has been identified and clarify by the proposer clearly. More-over with the experiences of the main contributor will lead the project more visible to be succeed. The point of feed back is related the project deliverable which are not open source but in some circumstance there is activity which potential will be part of the proposal to bring more visitor rather than just distributed the pamphlet.

The project team indicated that they have already held four similar events and have received good feedback. Therefore, there is high feasibility.The milestones are achievable

The proposal has indicated that the project team has received good feedback by holding similar events. This means they have a track record in delivering results.Therefore, the project has high feasibility.

The plan and budget provided is detailed and logical indicating that the project is achievable. Considering the team's experience they have proven to have the expertise and experience to make the project successful. The team has demonstrated that they have worked on similar project and and are well known in the Project catalyst. They have a positive track record in the implementation of similar programs. This is an indication that the proposal has a high feasibility rate.

The proposal mentions past experience in organizing similar events and the successful completion of projects funded by the Catalyst Fund. The team consists of capable individuals with experience as ambassadors, SPOs, and accountants. They also plan to involve professionals from the community in the project. This demonstrates their capability to deliver the project with trust and accountability.

Pros:

Cons:

This proposal team appears to already have been implementing a base version of this idea and gotten the feedback from the community. So, I think they could repeat the feat as required to continue to deliver the product. Although, they could repeat program activities, I find there are good enough information to carry the project. I find there are milestone and its targets that give me information who they measure for each their activities. About the team, I find lack information about bibliography of the team. Perhaps the proposer could provide the information about team member thus, we would know who they are and what are they capabilities. For the budget, they provide adequate information. Perhaps they could breakdown the budget into detail such as, cost for the brochure, cost of pamphlet and rent venue/day fo each exhibition. Although, there is lack of information, I find the information to implement the project is feasible. It just needs to touch up little bit, so that proposal look perfect

There is a detailed roadmap which has listed all the expo at the given month. Almost every month there would be an expo in Japan. The team did list their plans on what they are going to bring to the events (like inviting core developers/speakers) but would appreciate if the team put more information about what key content are in place, what are the difference going to be compared to last year (as mentioned by the author they have been funded for the event before). All in all, the proposal is feasible as given their past experience they know what they are doing, However, what would make this a perfect score would be the information on what the team are going to do differently compared to past events.

This project has shown that it is clearly feasible, firstly the team is experienced and has been carrying out similar projects in the past which was successful based on the statistics they provided. Furthermore, the budget demanded for the project is reasonable and can be seen from examining the milestone provided which has been clearly elaborated. So I think this project has a high rate of been successful.

The undertaking is doable. The proposal shows a well-defined project plan and budget, together with project milestones and particular tasks to be completed. The team appears to have the knowledge, expertise, and capacity to finish the project effectively. They have a history of putting on such events and have gotten positive reviews from the locals. The team's transparency in fund management and reporting is another indication of their accountability. High feasibility is proposed. The project team has proven that they are capable of completing the task with a high degree of accountability and trust. Four comparable events that they successfully arranged in the past have all been given the go-ahead. Furthermore, they actively participate in the Cardano ecosystem.

Their idea is smart and good. Showing Cardano at a big event will make more people know and trust it in Japan. They can also show how good and useful Cardano is, like how it uses science, research, green energy, and smart contracts. They can also bring Cardano experts to help and teach the people who come and want to make things with Cardano. They plans before and after the event are also good and well done. The team will use social media to tell people about their event and make them curious and excited. The team will also meet and help the people who come and work with them. The team will also ask them to join Catalyst and make their own ideas. Their idea is complete and powerful. I think it will make Cardano bigger and better in Japan and other places.

I think the proposal's aim to achieve the following targets is ambitious and realistic: -Awareness of Cardano = 6,000 visitors -Involvement in the Cardano ecosystem = 1,000 visitors -Companies participating in development = 5

I think these targets are ambitious because they require a lot of effort and resources to reach such a large and diverse audience. They will also need to have a strong and consistent social media presence, a reliable and supportive follow-up system, and a persuasive and inviting invitation to Catalyst.

I think these targets are realistic because they are based on the expected number of attendees at the expo, which is estimated to be around 30,000. You will also leverage the existing Cardano community in Japan, which has over 10,000 members. They will also benefit from the growing interest and demand for web3 solutions in Japan, which is supported by the government and the industry.

This proposal is intended to increase visibility and awareness of the Cardano ecosystem, and the overall goal is to attract more developers to the platform and encourage new adoption. The proposed solution addresses the challenge by creating opportunities for Cardano to be known through SNS and other means at exhibitions as well as pre- and post-exhibition promotional activities. It also increases the opportunity for developers to use Cardano by actively introducing development tools and inviting new Catalyst participants. The measurement of the success of the project will be done through counting the number of visitors, counting the number of SNS registrations, wallet downloads, requests, distribution of NFTs, number of groups submitting proposals to Catalyst and the number of companies involved in the development. The outputs and results of the project will be shared through social networking sites and also at community events to expand relationships with customers. Overall, the estimated impact of this proposed solution is positive, with benefits including increased exposure, increased interest, and increased opportunity.

The proposal aims to organize 2 Cardano exhibitions for the Japanese community, help increase awareness about Cardano, as well as introduce Catalyst to developers in Japan. I appreciate the project's impact and positive influence on the Cardano ecosystem

The idea conveyed by this project is great. I understand the project wants to introduce Cardano in trade shows aimed at increasing participation. I think that this will actually increase Cardano's exposure and bring more people into the Cardano ecosystem. This will be of great impact to the Cardano ecosystem. It's impact on the Cardano ecosystem will be undoubtedly great.

The proposal aims to address the challenge of limited exposure and awareness of Cardano in the blockchain space. By participating in several blockchain events, the project intends to increase Cardano's visibility and engage potential users and developers. The proposed solution demonstrates a positive impact on the Cardano ecosystem as it focuses on increasing Cardano's exposure, bringing more people into the ecosystem, and providing opportunities for developers to use Cardano.

Pros:

Cons:

The proposal goals is to continue the successful Cardano exhibition held at the largest blockchain expo in Japan. By involving well-known figures in the Cardano ecosystem, attracting participation from several companies, and reaching thousands of visitors, the project is will have a significant impact on the community. This impact will not only provide Cardano exposure to non-Cardano owners but also create opportunities for developers to engage in Cardano projects. Given the team's experience, the project has a high likelihood of success. The proposal is well-written, and in my opinion, the project deserves the funding it needs.

The idea to bring Cardano as one of exhibitor in one of the largest trade shows in Japan as part of product awarenness and recognition in development and application has potential bring high positive impact to bring more developer to develop their web3 application in Cardano Ecosystem. The marketing strategy through visible, product awareness, and communicate to the community will lead the interest for more future development in Cardano which will have beneficial to bring Cardano to the next level.

Focusing on face-to-face conversations and demonstrations will engage people to learn more about cardano. However, there will be limitations regarding the number of people that can be reached out to.

The project will be interactive because of the face-to-face conversations and demonstrations. However, the number of people interacted with may be limited.

As stated by the author, the awareness of Cardano is not as powerful compared to competition chains like Polygon, Solana, Etheruem and so on. Thus, the proposal aims to compete by attending to major events across Japan to promote Cardano. This would of course increase the chances of the awareness and in return more project could come abord Cardano and the developer ecosystem would flourish further. The author did mentioned that they would use pamphlets as a mean of introducing Cardano, but I believe the team should looks into making an NFT like Polygon did in some of their events as this would make it more interesting and hook the audience more. All in all, I still believe this proposal address the challenge.

This is a niche proposal to expand the Cardano in Japan. They argued that Cardano in Japan does not well-known compare to other blockchain platform. In addition to this, they want to promote and market it Cardano Blockchain in Japan. Since the Cardano does not recognize well in Japan, thus, distribute pamphlet and posting the poster in public is the good way for promotion. In addition, I agree with this move, thus, they also focus on face-to-face conversations and demonstrations, and multiple exhibits throughout the year to stimulate communication and increase participation. It is simple way to market Cardano blockchain but I think, it is the effective way and give impact to Cardano ecosystem. Furthermore, they provide the target quantitatively to measure impact of this program. At the same time, they are promising to give the report or information about pre- and post-exhibition promotional activities. It is what also suggested. In addition. Perhaps, In the final report they can provide quantitative report and qualitative report to the Cardano community. Thus, I give 5 star for this

The project's potential effects on the Cardano Ecosystem have yet been partially shown. The plan makes reference to improving Cardano's visibility and attracting new users to the ecosystem through exhibitions and promotional events, but the specifics and quantifiable results are not made explicit. There are gaps and omissions in the explanation of how the suggested solution can actually improve Cardano's visibility and draw new users to the ecosystem. The suggested impact is moderate. While the project seeks to make Cardano more well-known and generate interest through exhibitions and promotional events, there is a dearth of concrete proof or precise criteria to assess the efficacy of these initiatives. More precise and quantifiable measures of performance should be included in the plan.

This project will have a huge impact on the cardano community. Japan is well known for its technological advancement, so pushing the cardano projects in japan will bring positive advancement to the cardano community there by making it famous like Euthereum or Solano in the country. Most importantly the project has clearly demonstrated ways in which this will be beneficial to the cardano ecosystem and it can be seen based on statistics from their past project showing cardano can eventually take over a country like japan.