The problem described here fits into the challenge. One goal of this proposal is to provide education to African youth about Cardano and blockchain as a whole, and I believe that it’s a goal that aligns with the challenge setting, hence it would create more awareness about Cardano blockchain. In the long run, more African youth would be added to the ecosystem.

This entity is a new great addition to the Cardano community, what they bring into Cardano is a vast network of students, scholarships, workshops and potential employment opportunities. One only need to download their app to see their extent of their network. A unique achievement of this app is their endeavor into the Africa prior to joining Cardano. In conjunction with UNICEF, Goodwall became the platform where the youth of Ghana shared and brainstormed ideas on various topics. There ideas where then met by UNICEF who by working together found ways to materialize those ideas. Around 2000+ ideas came from this collaboration. Now they want to replicate and expand this idea together with Cardano. As Goodwall slowly introduces themselves into Cardano, it is highly likely numerous potential collaboration can be spawn from this union. At the very least, a joint program with UNICEF together with Goodwall to continue to build their work in Ghana. Or even a collaboration between Goodwall and WADA. It's only matter of time till beautiful collaborations will happen, especially since the introduction of Goodwall into Cardano was helped by Yoram. A collaborator in numerous Cardano communities and also involved in the develop of Cardano in Africa.

This is a nice idea. If I understand right you’re going to create the first content set, and then encourage people to start creating their own content and sharing it in the platform. I’ve seem some other complementary ideas in this challenge that you could work together and help each other.

The fact of working with an already stablished platform that has clearly an impact on African countries is a major advantage when we think about spread new content, and if this goes as planned it’ll be in good use of African community and ADA community as well, since it’s expected that you increase the amount of devs working with ADA.

This proposal focuses on educating African youth on blockchain technology through the creation of educational content, videos, and speaker sessions, as well as engage youth to raise awareness of how blockchain can be used to drive social impact, which is what the Grow Africa, Grow Cardano challenge aims to achieve, and thus it effectively addresses the challenge.

Through Goodwall learning sessions, the proposal's purpose is to educate African children on the basics of blockchain and the Cardano ecosystem. I believe that this project will have a long-term impact on Cardano because Goodwall is a worldwide platform utilized in over 150 countries, with the majority of users ranging in age from 16 to 24, a very energetic and willing to learn new things. Not only does Goodwall provide instructive content, but it also encourages users to contribute ideas to Project Catalyst via Cardano group talks, which I believe will eventually expand the number of Cardano ideas and activities.

The program's goal is to raise awareness of blockchain technology in Africa, which is very much in accordance with the challenge's requirement.

It denotes expertise in the topic of education in other areas as they already have an infrastructure in place and are not creating it from scratch.

The program is focused on the usage of blockchain in general, so it is certainly important for Cardano, but I would want the subjects to be much more focused on how to utilize it in the Cardano ecosystem, because the description leads me to believe it is quite generic.

Even though the younger generations have easy access to technology, it is undeniable that schools and institutions do not have preparations in place to teach blockchain-related issues, as a result, the impact of such a project is critical.

The proposal is aligned to the challenge. The information in the proposal reveals the need of leverage on Godwall’s first mobile platform to educate the community about blockchain, Cardano and the entrepreneurial opportunities. The media information provided is sufficient to attain the project objectives and to create a great global impact. The proposal is potentially scalable. Grow Cardano, Grow Africa, seed in educating and engaging youths.

I believe the problem described is closely related with the change objectives. This proposal aims at educating the youth in Africa on the ABCs of the blockchain technology it’s applications and social impact possibilities on them and their communities through learning programs on goodwall. This initiative will grow the Cardano community by maximizing the potential of the youth of Africa by sharing educational content in multiple languages.

Goodwall has built a large user base, mostly young people, which is a huge strength. The project should link with the Cardano communities through communication channels such as telegram, facebook to increase interactivity on blockchain orientation, about Cardano… And in the project development process, the application of Cardano should be integrated into practice such as creating NFT identifiers for articles, videos … both granting copyright and making a good impression on the Goodwall community. Here are a few of my suggestions, but Goodwall's impact is remarkable, happy to give it a 4

The problem stated in the proposal clearly aligns with the challenge. The solution also solves the challenge, which means we can continue to seed and grow cardano in Africa in 2022 by educating youths in Africa on the basics of blockchain,it's applications and social impact possibilities via experiential learning programs on a social platform called Goodwall which connects about 2million individuals across 150+ countries guiding and educating them. To me per say, this is a very brilliant idea and kudos to the team . This idea will serve as a means of drawing individuals unto the cardano ecosystem and hence making them become members of catalyst. Creating content about the cardano ecosystem on this platform(Goodwill)will help youths maximize their potential and impact society by means of cardano. This project if funded will have a successful impact on cardano since about millions of youths will get access to cardano Content created on the platform (Goodwill).

The 'Grow Africa, Grow Cardano’ challenge seeks to expand the knowledge of Cardano in Africa and this proposal clearly intends to do so. The proposal also clearly demonstrates Cardano tech use-case solutions since it is stated that it will energize the community about how Cardano tech solutions can be used. If about 12% of 2 million youth are being reached on the Goodwall platform, then it enlarges local impact and will go a long way to ensure that Cardano is the blockchain of choice in Africa by 2023. Hence, I strongly agree that this proposal effectively addresses the challenge.

Impact Assessment: Rating of 4 "The proposal strives to bridge the gap between the Cardano ecosystem and the entire Africa Continent. This is a huge project to be executed steadily. The problem demonstrated in this proposal is closely linked to the challenge. As appreciated by the proposal, it is wealthy to note the dynamics of French and English speaking African Countries to establish a common platform. I believe this project will bring forth a positive results as it is determined to provide more insight into youth interest and behavior around blockchain. I stand to be a living testimony of how my Junior brother who is a veteran Community Advisor, and currently working on a funded project, ushered me into the Cardano community to better understand the good packages Cardano has got. The key metrics and goals of the proposal align with the outlined challenge settings. The proposal acknowledges future challenges to encounter.

Proposing to expand education and entrepreneurship opportunities for young Africans about knowledge of Lockchain technology through the Goodwall curriculum. The proposal has a clear solution to develop education, share ideas of African youth across the continent and develop Cardano. The proponent has foreseen the risks and has solutions for the risks when proposing. export is implemented.

The Future of Cardano is African. This proposal is a very good idea that can take advantage of the Goodwall platform with more than 2 million members who are very young aged 16-24. Successfully reaching over 4.2 million young people in Ghana shows that it has a lot of potential to be able to help the Cardano community in Africa grow rapidly. Organizing lessons for young people aged 16-24 on the Goodwall platform about blockchain and the Cardano ecosystem will help a large number of young people in Africa have faster access to technology. It's a great combination and it's perfectly up to the challenge.

The main objective of the proposal is to promote content about Cardano and about blockchain in general through a teaching platform. We have here that the main differential, in addition to the creation of quality content, is in this platform. Instead of spending and planning in relation to logistics and infrastructure, it is possible to be primarily concerned with the quality of the content being produced and the engagement of the public around it, as there is a whole network already validated by millions of users. With that, we have that this proposal fits the challenge in question, since this content will be produced with a focus on Africa and will be available in languages ​​that are widely spoken nationally. Furthermore, with a good performance of the project, it is expected that more people from the continent will show interest in participating in the ecosystem, including contributing with business ideas. Certainly the project has a good chance of having a positive impact on Cardano's visibility, in addition to being naturally scalable. About the budget being requested of $37,500 we see that it is higher than in other similar proposals aimed at education, but this is justified due to the structure of the platform and the team involved.

The roadmap provided is detailed and there are also comprehensive milestones and time horizon. The metrics/KPIs are very clear as we can tell the number of impressions, engagements and challenge entries that are expected to be realized, and they are good indicators of the desired outcome. The described problem here is clear, and the solution provided is good to tackle the problem.

They indeed have provided to us a document that portrays their standard in reporting, which is comprehensive, visually easy to understand and to an extent we can imagine quite transparent. Why quite transparent? Because their metrics come from the date retrieved from their app. A strength and a weakness. Seeing that the culture of Cardano is majority open-source, perhaps some might find centralized report to be bothering. Some might feel the numbers can be tampered. Since it is a cultural thing, perhaps in the future, Goodwall could consider a decentralized system in reporting. Perhaps through the use of GitHub. Beside that, everything else looks great, they even have mentioned will provide a Google drive for all their documentation and recorded information.

Since all the content are going to be uploaded in the platform, I think that there will be no difficulty to audit.

It would be nice to include a survey box to evaluate the quality of the prepared course.

It would be interesting to have a ADA payment method in the platform.

This proposer states their goals and defines success as receiving video entries demonstrating Cardano tech use-case solutions from Africa. It is sufficient to audit the proposal's development and success because it provides a clear explanation of the targeted problem as well as a solution that solves the problem in a comparable manner.

The KPIs, roadmap, milestones are defined. The proposer commits to provide a google folder in the community to audit the progress and success of the proposal and its sufficient to serve the purpose. However, the delivery dates were not clearly defined.

The plan provides a clear technique for tracking progress as well as a realistic and measurable definition of success. I'd add one more metric to monitor: the ratio of positive to negative user comments (this could be used from the survey in the program result phase).

The given project indicators are quite consistent and easy to quantify. I can suggest a few more methods like “video views, videos uploaded”, which are both simple and very intuitive. At the same time, you should consider creating a list on the Goodwall Youtube channel to aggregate blockchain videos that can be globally popular in the future.

There are clear KPIs, but for this type of project it would be important to analytics of the data they manage, how many people took the course, what age, how many finished, how many did not, from which locations in Africa, and in general the demographics of each person, these are just examples of what could be achieved, with this data could be improved in the future of people who start and finish, and have information on which people are being reached, so as to seize the opportunity.

The success of this proposal is achievable as the metrics and the key indicators are stated clearly, can be understood and can be measured and audited.

I personally think this proposal will be highly auditable by the community since a Google folder will be made available to the community with all recorded information and documentations about the project. Also content like videos, animations that demonstrate cardano technology will clearly be kept on the platform (Goodwill) to access when you log in. The KPIs are also stated but the number of performances they hope to achieve was too much but then I believe with determination the team will definitely achieve their aims.

Auditability Assessment: Rating of 4

The proposal establishes its internal KPIs which are in conformity with that of the challenge and would assist in assessing and measuring the project performance. There is a clear definition of internal KPIs set up by the team to ease understanding. Local impact is set to be achieved once the project is funded and the roadmap is very well set out and would make auditing more easier and faster.

The proposal includes a roadmap with milestones and a time frame for completion, as well as metrics and key performance indicators (KPIs) that define the proposal's success. The proposal includes a clear explanation of the targeted problem, as well as a solution that solves the problem in a comparable manner. Thus, the information provided is sufficient to audit the progress and the success of the proposal.

Progress to measure project success transparently, on screen, video, Goodwall. The blueprint shows the success of the proposal. Towards Development Africa and Cardano. New proposals and great ideas will make Africa and Cardano grow more widely.

The roadmap for implementing this proposal is also very complete and clear. I believe that you have prepared very well for the success of this proposal. However, there is one issue I would like to suggest to you, which is that you need to be more transparent in the use of the $37500 amount. For example, need to be more specific about how $4470 is used for program design? How is $7108 spent on specific advertising?… In general, the more detailed and transparent you are with each amount, the more the community appreciates you. The KPIs you give are also very clear and easy to measure. I believe the community also appreciates this.

In line with the entire structuring of the proposal so far, we also found very consistent information both on ways to measure the project's progress and on the perception of success. It is even interesting to see how these two pieces of information are related in this section. For example, impression and engagement were two concepts chosen to measure the progress of the proposal. And when explaining the success, the team quantified these ideas into well-defined numerical goals; 1 million impressions and 30,000 engagements as milestones to reach.

Other information relevant to the auditability of the project can actually be found even earlier, when we see the team's concern to carry out an analysis of results and a survey in the final weeks of the project.